Hagmar L, Bellander T, Ranstam J, Skerfving S
Am J Ind Med. 1984;6(5):347-57. doi: 10.1002/ajim.4700060505.
The heterocyclic secondary amine piperazine is known to cause asthma. In a cohort of 602 workers, employed during the period 1942-1979, at a chemical industry where piperazine is handled, a study conducted by means of a mailed questionnaire showed a strong exposure-response relationship as to frequency of work-related airway symptoms indicating asthma. In the most exposed group about a third of the workers had experienced such symptoms. Age, length of employment, smoking habits, and previous work-related asthmatic symptoms, but not atopy, modified the response. Further, there was an association between piperazine exposure and chronic bronchitis. In the most exposed group every fourth subject had chronic bronchitis. The frequency was modified by smoking habits; atopy was a confounder. Although many subjects, especially high-exposed ones, left work because of airway symptoms, there was no difference in occurrence of airway symptoms between former and present employees, ie, no "healthy worker selection" ("survivor population effect").
已知杂环仲胺哌嗪可引发哮喘。在1942年至1979年期间受雇于一家处理哌嗪的化工行业的602名工人队列中,通过邮寄问卷进行的一项研究表明,与工作相关的气道症状(提示哮喘)的发生频率存在强烈的暴露-反应关系。在暴露程度最高的组中,约三分之一的工人曾出现过此类症状。年龄、工作年限、吸烟习惯以及既往与工作相关的哮喘症状(而非特应性)会改变反应。此外,哌嗪暴露与慢性支气管炎之间存在关联。在暴露程度最高的组中,每四名受试者中就有一人患有慢性支气管炎。其频率受吸烟习惯影响;特应性是一个混杂因素。尽管许多受试者,尤其是高暴露者,因气道症状而离职,但 former和现任员工在气道症状的发生方面并无差异,即不存在“健康工人效应”(“幸存者效应”)。