Houtz T D, Brooks M A, Wenk R E, Dawson R B
Forensic Sci Int. 1981 May-Jun;17(3):211-8. doi: 10.1016/0379-0738(81)90169-9.
Six erythrocyte antigen systems and the HLA system were evaluated to establish their practical value in 500 cases of disputed paternity. The actual results were very close to predicted values. HLA testing is expected to detect 92% and red cell testing is expected to detect 67% of men falsely accused in paternity suits. The findings of this study show that HLA detected 94% and red cell testing detected 69% of 107 men falsely accused in 500 paternity cases. In order of sensitivity, Rh, MNSs, and ABO were the most useful erythrocyte marker systems. There were six out of 107 cases in which exclusions would have been undetected if red cell typing had not been performed. Five of the six cases involved "common" HLA haplotypes.
对六个红细胞抗原系统和HLA系统进行了评估,以确定它们在500例亲权纠纷案件中的实际价值。实际结果与预测值非常接近。预计HLA检测可在亲权诉讼中检测出92%被错误指控的男性,红细胞检测预计可检测出67%。本研究结果表明,在500例亲权案件中,HLA检测出了107名被错误指控男性中的94%,红细胞检测出了69%。按敏感性排序,Rh、MNSs和ABO是最有用的红细胞标记系统。在107例案件中,如果未进行红细胞分型,有6例的排除情况将无法被检测到。这6例中的5例涉及“常见”HLA单倍型。