Radhakrishna S, Nair N G, Kachirayan M, Ramanathan A M
Tubercle. 1980 Dec;61(4):221-9. doi: 10.1016/0041-3879(80)90042-2.
This paper demonstrates that when 'spot' specimens of sputum are cultured for tubercle bacilli on Löwenstein-Jensen medium, bacterial contamination occurs at random and follows a Poisson distribution. Over a period of 14 years, contamination rates with overnight 'collection' specimens (4.5 to 10.2%) were substantially higher than with spot specimens (1.3 to 4.0%), but the correlation between the two was very high (r = 0.98). In contrast to spot specimens, the incidence of contamination with collection specimens was significantly higher for females than for males, and significant variation was also found between patients of the same sex. In consequence, the Poisson distribution, which assumes a constant contamination rate for all patients, did not provide a satisfactory fit to the data on collection specimens. However, a negative binomial distribution, which incorporates individual variability in contamination rate, provided a good fit. The reasons for individual variability are discussed.
本文表明,当在罗氏培养基上对痰的“即时”标本进行结核杆菌培养时,细菌污染是随机发生的,且遵循泊松分布。在14年的时间里,过夜“采集”标本的污染率(4.5%至10.2%)显著高于即时标本(1.3%至4.0%),但两者之间的相关性非常高(r = 0.98)。与即时标本不同,采集标本的污染发生率女性显著高于男性,且在同性患者之间也发现了显著差异。因此,假定所有患者污染率恒定的泊松分布并不能很好地拟合采集标本的数据。然而,纳入污染率个体变异性的负二项分布则拟合良好。文中讨论了个体变异性的原因。