Pécoud A, Bonstein H S, Frei P C
Clin Allergy. 1983 Mar;13(2):141-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2222.1983.tb02581.x.
Detailed histories taken in eighty-one patients suffering from perennial asthma and rhinitis were analysed independently by three trained allergists and their conclusions were compared to the results of three tests: (1) concentration of total serum IgE; (2) skin tests and (3) radioallergosorbent test (RAST). In eleven patients (14%), the three investigators disagreed when estimating the allergic nature of the symptoms. Ten out of forty-four patients (23%), unanimously predicted not to be allergic, had high levels of total serum IgE and skin tests and RAST clearly positive for one or more allergens. The allergists suspected 47% of the allergens detected by skin tests and 55% of those detected by RAST. The case history was the test which most often gave information at odds with that suggested by the other three tests. Our study indicates therefore that a case history not even suggestive of allergy should be complemented by additional tests.
三位训练有素的过敏症专科医生分别对81例常年性哮喘和鼻炎患者的详细病史进行了分析,并将他们的结论与三项检测结果进行了比较:(1)血清总IgE浓度;(2)皮肤试验;(3)放射变应原吸附试验(RAST)。在11名患者(14%)中,三位研究者在评估症状的过敏性质时意见不一致。在44名一致预测无过敏的患者中,有10名(23%)血清总IgE水平较高,皮肤试验和RAST对一种或多种变应原呈明显阳性。过敏症专科医生怀疑皮肤试验检测出的变应原中有47%,RAST检测出的变应原中有55%。病史是最常提供与其他三项检测结果不一致信息的检测方法。因此,我们的研究表明,即使病史未提示过敏,也应通过额外的检测加以补充。