Goldman H H, Adams N H, Taube C A
Hosp Community Psychiatry. 1983 Feb;34(2):129-34. doi: 10.1176/ps.34.2.129.
Many past studies of data on deinstitutionalization have used an overly simplistic and often misleading approach, which has led to a number of "myths" of deinstitutionalization. The authors present data on the changing mental health service system collected by the Division of Biometry and Epidemiology of the National Institute of Mental Health, and they analyze the data to reveal trends that disprove a number of the commonly accepted myths. Through their analysis they show that outpatient care has not replaced inpatient care, that public institutions, particularly state mental hospitals, have not been replaced by community-based facilities, and that private resources have not replaced public ones as the bearer of the cost of caring for the mentally ill. They conclude that the availability and quality of mental health services and the effect of these services on patients and their communities are difficult issues for future research.
过去许多关于非机构化的数据研究采用了过于简单化且常常具有误导性的方法,这导致了一些关于非机构化的“神话”。作者展示了美国国立精神卫生研究所生物统计学与流行病学部门收集的不断变化的心理健康服务系统的数据,并对这些数据进行分析,以揭示一些趋势,这些趋势反驳了许多普遍接受的“神话”。通过分析,他们表明门诊护理并没有取代住院护理,公共机构,尤其是州立精神病医院,并没有被社区设施所取代,并且私人资源并没有取代公共资源来承担照顾精神病患者的费用。他们得出结论,心理健康服务的可及性和质量以及这些服务对患者及其社区的影响是未来研究的难题。