Kilbourne B K, Kilbourne M T
Int J Soc Psychiatry. 1983 Autumn;29(3):173-9. doi: 10.1177/002076408302900302.
The present study investigated the reported feelings of power and dependency of chronic neuropsychiatric patients in a sheltered workshop. Self-evaluations of dependency were assessed in relation to one real-life role (i.e. disabled welfare recipient), and evaluations of power feelings were assessed in relation to another real life role (i.e. worker in a sheltered workshop), with a complementary work-related performance measure. While dependency and power feelings were independent of each other, it was also found that: 1) dependency feelings positively predicted the number of mental hospital admissions; and 2) feelings of power in the workshop negatively predicted work performance. These results provide direct evidence that feelings of dependency and power can be role specific and not indicative of generalized behaviours. They also provide indirect evidence of a role theory interpretation of learned helplessnesslike phenomena.
本研究调查了在庇护工厂中慢性神经精神疾病患者所报告的权力感和依赖感。依赖感的自我评估是针对一个现实生活角色(即残疾福利领取者)进行的,权力感的评估则是针对另一个现实生活角色(即庇护工厂的工人)进行的,同时还采用了一项与工作相关的补充绩效指标。虽然依赖感和权力感相互独立,但研究还发现:1)依赖感能正向预测精神病院住院次数;2)在工厂中的权力感能负向预测工作表现。这些结果提供了直接证据,表明依赖感和权力感可能具有角色特异性,并非普遍行为的体现。它们还为习得性无助现象的角色理论解释提供了间接证据。