Watkins L, Mower M M, Reid P R, Platia E V, Griffith L S, Mirowski M
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1983 Sep;86(3):381-7.
Since February, 1980, 65 survivors of multiple arrhythmic cardiac arrests unresponsive to therapy were referred for implantation of the automatic defibrillator. In 37 patients (Group I), automatic defibrillator implantation alone was performed by subxiphoid insertion (20 patients) or thoracotomy (17 patients). In another 28 patients (Group II), implantation was combined with definitive cardiac procedures--coronary artery bypass grafting in seven patients, bypass grafting and mitral valve replacement in four patients, and left ventricular aneurysmectomy with endocardial resection in 17 patients. There were no surgical deaths in Group I; four operative deaths occurred in Group II. The longest follow-up has been 34 months, average 15.6 months. Following hospital discharge, 44 episodes of automatic out-of-hospital resuscitation were observed in 11 Group I patients. Similarly, four resuscitations were observed in two Group II patients. Hypothetical survival curves based on the assumption that these out-of-hospital resuscitations were lifesaving indicated expected 1 year survivals rates of 45% in Group I and 85% in Group II. Excluding the perioperative deaths that were unrelated to the defibrillator, the actual 1 year survival rates observed were 75% and 95% in Groups I and II, respectively. Although definitive operation markedly reduced the number of out-of-hospital arrhythmic episodes, the automatic defibrillator appears to increase survival both when implanted alone and when used in combination with cardiac procedures.
自1980年2月以来,65名对治疗无反应的多次心律失常性心脏骤停幸存者被转诊接受自动除颤器植入。在37例患者(第一组)中,单独通过剑突下插入(20例患者)或开胸手术(17例患者)进行自动除颤器植入。在另外28例患者(第二组)中,植入与确定性心脏手术相结合——7例患者进行冠状动脉搭桥术,4例患者进行搭桥术和二尖瓣置换术,17例患者进行左心室室壁瘤切除术和心内膜切除术。第一组无手术死亡;第二组发生4例手术死亡。最长随访时间为34个月,平均15.6个月。出院后,在第一组的11例患者中观察到44次院外自动复苏事件。同样,在第二组的2例患者中观察到4次复苏。基于这些院外复苏具有挽救生命作用这一假设的生存曲线表明,第一组预期1年生存率为45%,第二组为85%。排除与除颤器无关的围手术期死亡,第一组和第二组实际观察到的1年生存率分别为75%和95%。尽管确定性手术显著减少了院外心律失常事件的数量,但自动除颤器单独植入以及与心脏手术联合使用时似乎都能提高生存率。