Spriet A, Fermanian J, Simon P
Encephale. 1978;4(2):119-29.
Rating scales are used to assess the intensity of psychiatric attributes such as anxiety and depression: they are generally composed of several items to be rated. They postulate: the continuity of the "measured" attribute; a monotonic attribute-item scores relationship; and the cancellation, within the final score of "parasitic" factors due to other features than the one which it is desired to measure. The main metrologic qualities are: sensitivity to states of different intensities, reliability in respect to time and rater, validity: relative to an external clinical classification, to another rating scale, or to known efficacy of a treament on the studied attribute. Self-rating scales avoid an intermediate rater and are easy to use. But they allow for no interpretation from external information, and cannot be used in patients with linguistic difficulties, or severely impaired. Scales rated by a rater consist of codification of a well-conducted interview. They allow for correction of erroneous answers from the patients. They may be affected by certain systematic rater errors (attenuation, central or extreme tendency, halo effect, etc...) which are decreased by training. The global score can be obtained by summing item scores, or from a factor analysis. Construction of a rating scale is a difficult task which implies a series of approximations to obtain, from an initial collection of items, satisfactory metrologic qualities. Translation and adaptation of a rating scale are difficult manoeuvres, which may jeopardize its validity.
它们通常由若干需要评定的项目组成。它们假定:“被测量”属性的连续性;属性与项目得分之间的单调关系;以及在最终得分中消除由于除想要测量的特征之外的其他特征导致的“寄生”因素。主要的计量学质量包括:对不同强度状态的敏感性、相对于时间和评定者的可靠性、有效性:相对于外部临床分类、相对于另一个评定量表或相对于已知治疗对所研究属性的疗效。自评量表避免了中间评定者,且易于使用。但它们无法根据外部信息进行解释,并且不能用于有语言困难或严重受损的患者。由评定者评定的量表包括对一次进行良好的访谈的编码。它们允许对患者的错误答案进行纠正。它们可能会受到某些系统性评定者误差(减弱、集中或极端倾向、光环效应等)的影响,而通过培训可以减少这些误差。总分可以通过将项目得分相加或通过因子分析获得。评定量表的构建是一项艰巨的任务,这意味着要进行一系列近似处理,以便从最初的项目集合中获得令人满意的计量学质量。评定量表的翻译和改编是困难的操作,可能会损害其有效性。