Gupta G, Bansal M, Sasisekharan V
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1980 Nov;77(11):6486-90. doi: 10.1073/pnas.77.11.6486.
It is shown that left-handed duplexes are possible for A, B, and D forms of DNA. These duplexes are stereochemically satisfactory and are consistent with the observed x-ray intensity data. On scrutiny the refined right-handed models of B and D DNA by Arnott and coworkers are found to be stereochemically unacceptable. It was possible to formulate a stereochemical guideline for molecular model building based on theory and analysis of single-crystal structure data of dinucleoside monophosphate and higher oligomers. This led to both right- and left-handed DNA duplexes. The right-handed B and D DNA duplexes so obtained are stereochemically superior to earlier models and agree well with the observed x-ray intensity data. The observation that DNA can exist in either handedness for all the polymorphous forms of DNA at once explained A in equilibrium B and B in equilibrium D transitions. Hence it is confirmed that polymorphism of DNA is a reflection on the conformational flexibility inherent in DNA, the same cause that ultimately allows DNA in either handedness. The possibility of various types of right- and left-handed duplexes generated by using dinucleoside monophosphate and trinucleoside diphosphate as repeating units resulted in a variety of models, called RL models. All these models have alternating right and left helical segments and inverted stacking at the bend region as suggested by us earlier. It turns out that the B-Z DNA model of Wang et al. is only an example of RL models.
结果表明,DNA的A、B和D型都可能存在左手双螺旋结构。这些双螺旋结构在立体化学上是令人满意的,并且与观察到的X射线强度数据一致。经仔细研究发现,阿诺特及其同事提出的B型和D型DNA的精制右手模型在立体化学上是不可接受的。基于对单磷酸二核苷及更高寡聚物单晶结构数据的理论和分析,有可能制定出分子模型构建的立体化学指导原则。这导致了右手和左手DNA双螺旋结构的出现。由此获得的右手B型和D型DNA双螺旋结构在立体化学上优于早期模型,并且与观察到的X射线强度数据非常吻合。DNA的所有多晶型形式都能以两种旋向存在这一观察结果,立刻解释了A与B的平衡转变以及B与D的平衡转变。因此可以确定,DNA的多态性反映了DNA固有的构象灵活性,正是这一相同原因最终使得DNA能够呈现两种旋向。使用单磷酸二核苷和二磷酸三核苷作为重复单元生成各种类型的右手和左手双螺旋结构的可能性,导致了多种模型的出现,称为RL模型。所有这些模型都有交替的右手和左手螺旋片段,并且如我们之前所提出的,在弯曲区域存在反向堆积。结果表明,王等人提出的B-Z DNA模型只是RL模型中的一个例子。