Craig J, Cooper G M, Sear J W
Br J Anaesth. 1982 Apr;54(4):447-51. doi: 10.1093/bja/54.4.447.
One hundred unpremedicated patients, undergoing short gynaecological procedures, were randomly allocated to receive one of three i.v. hypnotic agents (methohexitone, Althesin and etomidate) alone or in combination with fentanyl, to supplement 66% nitrous oxide in oxygen. Recovery was assessed by the time patients took to open the eyes, to give correct date of birth, to achieve a certain level of manipulative skill with a children's post-box toy, and to perform a paper and pencil test. Satisfactory operating conditions were not obtained using etomidate alone. Administration of methohexitone alone resulted in a more rapid initial awakening than Althesin alone (P less than 0.05) and the administration of fentanyl with methohexitone reduced the total dose given of the latter (P less than 0.01). Administration of fentanyl with Althesin or methohexitone did not significantly prolong the "post-box" recovery time. Side-effects were less common with Althesin, with or without fentanyl and etomidate with fentanyl was associated with the greatest frequency of complications.
100例未接受术前用药、即将接受短期妇科手术的患者被随机分配,单独接受三种静脉催眠药(美索比妥、阿法沙龙/阿法多龙合剂和依托咪酯)之一,或与芬太尼联合使用,以补充66%的氧化亚氮-氧气混合气。通过患者睁眼所需时间、说出正确出生日期所需时间、使用儿童邮箱玩具达到一定操作技能水平所需时间以及进行纸笔测试的情况来评估恢复情况。单独使用依托咪酯时无法获得满意的手术条件。单独使用美索比妥比单独使用阿法沙龙/阿法多龙合剂导致初始苏醒更快(P<0.05),美索比妥与芬太尼联合使用可减少美索比妥的总给药剂量(P<0.01)。芬太尼与阿法沙龙/阿法多龙合剂或美索比妥联合使用并未显著延长“邮箱”恢复时间。阿法沙龙/阿法多龙合剂无论是否与芬太尼联合使用,副作用都较少,而依托咪酯与芬太尼联合使用时并发症发生率最高。