Sheldahl L M, Buskirk E R, Loomis J L, Hodgson J L, Mendez J
Int J Obes. 1982;6(1):29-42.
Seven obese women (greater than 30 per cent body fat, mean = 43 per cent) performed moderate exercise (30 to 40 per cent of maximal oxygen consumption) for 90 min during head-out immersion in cool water (17 to 22 degrees C) five times per week for eight weeks to determine if cold exposure and the attendant caloric deficit in body heat stores would lead to body weight loss. Exercise was on a cycle ergometer that was modified for underwater use. Body weight, body fat, fat-free body weight, and caloric intake did not change significantly as a result of the exercise program in cool water. The significant heat debts incurred were presumably repaid without an increase in energy expenditure. The caloric balance and the thermal data obtained suggest that body heat stores were slowly repaid during recovery by resting metabolic heat production associated with a reduced rate of body heat loss. Maximal oxygen uptake did not increase significantly. No metabolic or thermal evidence was found to support cold adaptation in the obese women. Ergometer exercise in water as well-tolerated, as evidenced by no exercise-related injuries and an adherence rate of 93 per cent. It was concluded that, while cold exposure does not increase caloric expenditure significantly in obese individuals, exercising regularly in cool water may be beneficial as it may motivate obese people to exercise at higher intensity for thermal comfort and the water environment may help prevent injuries.
七名肥胖女性(体脂率超过30%,平均为43%)在头部露出水面浸泡于冷水(17至22摄氏度)中的状态下,每周进行五次、每次90分钟的中等强度运动(最大耗氧量的30%至40%),持续八周,以确定冷暴露及随之而来的身体热量储存中的热量不足是否会导致体重减轻。运动使用的是一台为水下使用而改装的自行车测力计。冷水运动项目并未使体重、体脂、去脂体重和热量摄入发生显著变化。所产生的显著热债大概是在能量消耗未增加的情况下得到偿还的。所获得的热量平衡和热数据表明,在恢复过程中,身体热量储存是通过与身体热量散失速率降低相关的静息代谢产热而缓慢得到补充的。最大摄氧量没有显著增加。未发现代谢或热方面的证据支持肥胖女性存在冷适应现象。测力计水上运动耐受性良好,未出现与运动相关的损伤,依从率为93%。研究得出结论,虽然冷暴露在肥胖个体中不会显著增加热量消耗,但在冷水中定期锻炼可能有益,因为这可能促使肥胖者为了获得热舒适而以更高强度进行锻炼,并且水环境可能有助于预防损伤。