Sutherland C J, Wilde A H, Borden L S, Marks K E
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1982 Sep;64(7):970-82.
One hundred consecutive Müller curved-stem total hip replacements were reviewed ten years after operation. Twenty patients with twenty-two arthroplasties had died within the ten-year period without having a revision, and twenty-five arthroplasties had been revised for various reasons. Of the remaining fifty-three arthroplasties, thirty-five were classified as good or excellent, with Harris hip scores of 80 points or higher, and eighteen were classified as poor or fair, with scores lower than 80 points. Follow-up radiographs, made for all but six of the fifty-three hips at ten years, showed a 23 per cent incidence of migration of the acetabular component and a 28 per cent incidence of migration of the femoral component. In addition, there was a 15 per cent incidence of bone resorption in the proximal end of the femur without migration of the femoral component and a 4 per cent incidence of osteolytic defects about the femoral component, also without migration. Combining the radiographically loose replacement (migration) with the clinically loose ones (revised), the over-all incidence of aseptic loosening was 29 per cent for the acetabular component and 40 per cent for the femoral component. There was a positive correlation between the incidence of loosening of the femoral component and younger age, heavier weight, male sex, unilateral hip disease, a wide femoral canal, and varus position of the femoral component, whereas the incidence of loosening of the acetabular component was increased only in association with older age. The rate of loosening of the femoral component appeared to be higher during the early follow-up period and to decrease with time, while the rate of loosening of the acetabular component appeared to be lower during the early follow-up period but to increase with time.
对连续100例采用Müller弯柄全髋关节置换术的患者进行了术后10年的随访。20例患者(共22个关节成形术)在10年期间死亡,未进行翻修,另有25个关节成形术因各种原因进行了翻修。在其余53个关节成形术中,35个被评为良好或优秀,Harris髋关节评分80分及以上,18个被评为差或一般,评分低于80分。对53个髋关节中的除6个之外的所有髋关节在术后10年进行了随访X线检查,结果显示髋臼组件移位发生率为23%,股骨组件移位发生率为28%。此外,在股骨近端有15%的骨吸收发生率,此时股骨组件未发生移位,在股骨组件周围有4%的溶骨性缺损发生率,同样股骨组件也未发生移位。将影像学上松动的置换(移位)与临床上松动的(翻修)相结合,髋臼组件无菌性松动的总体发生率为29%,股骨组件为40%。股骨组件松动发生率与年龄较轻、体重较重、男性、单侧髋关节疾病、股骨髓腔宽大以及股骨组件内翻位呈正相关,而髋臼组件松动发生率仅在年龄较大时增加。股骨组件松动率在早期随访期间似乎较高,随时间下降,而髋臼组件松动率在早期随访期间似乎较低,但随时间增加。