Jones E E
J Clin Psychol. 1982 Oct;38(4):722-31. doi: 10.1002/1097-4679(198210)38:4<722::aid-jclp2270380406>3.0.co;2-7.
One hundred sixty-four black and white patients, evenly divided by race, were seen in individual psychotherapy for a mean of more than 31 treatment hours. Half the patients in each group were in racially similar therapist-patient matches and half in racially dissimilar pairings. Assessments of treatment outcomes and personality descriptions of patients were obtained from therapists after termination. White therapists generally rated their clients, and especially their black clients, as psychologically more impaired than did black therapists. Adjective descriptions revealed important differences in the perception of black and white clients by therapists of the two races. In the view of therapists, all patients improved as a result of treatment, and black and white patients, with few exceptions, appeared to benefit about equally. Contrary to expectation, there were no differences in psychotherapy outcome as a function of client-therapist racial match.
164名黑人和白人患者,按种族平均分配,接受了平均超过31个治疗小时的个体心理治疗。每组患者中有一半是种族匹配的治疗师-患者组合,另一半是种族不匹配的组合。治疗结束后,从治疗师那里获得了对治疗结果的评估和患者的性格描述。白人治疗师通常认为他们的客户,尤其是黑人客户,在心理上比黑人治疗师认为的受损更严重。形容词描述揭示了两个种族的治疗师对黑人和白人客户看法的重要差异。在治疗师看来,所有患者都因治疗而有所改善,黑人和白人患者几乎都同样受益。与预期相反,心理治疗结果与客户-治疗师种族匹配无关。