Fineberg B L, Sowards S K, Kettlewell P W
Adolescence. 1980 Winter;15(60):913-25.
This review summarizes many of the major issues and findings appearing over the last 40 years in the descriptive, theoretical, and experimental literature about adolescent inpatient treatment. The discussion of program design emphasizes the milieu, psychotherapy modalities, and the mixed vs all-adolescent ward controversy. Treatment theory proposes corrective relationships, internalization of external controls and structure, and conflict resolution as the dynamic agents for therapeutic change. There are disputes about whether short or long hospital stays are optimal for these agents to do their work. Despite methodological problems, follow-up research supports the effectiveness of inpatient care for adolescents. Some suggestions are made for improving the understanding of the patient characteristics and treatment ingredients relevant to positive outcome through more comprehensive research questions and collaborative work.
本综述总结了过去40年里在关于青少年住院治疗的描述性、理论性和实验性文献中出现的许多主要问题和研究结果。对项目设计的讨论强调了治疗环境、心理治疗方式以及混合病房与全青少年病房之争。治疗理论提出,矫正性人际关系、外部控制和结构的内化以及冲突解决是治疗改变的动态因素。对于这些因素发挥作用而言,住院时间长短哪种更优存在争议。尽管存在方法学问题,但随访研究支持青少年住院治疗的有效性。通过更全面的研究问题和合作,提出了一些建议,以增进对与积极治疗结果相关的患者特征和治疗要素的理解。