Okun M A, Stock W A, Ceurvorst R W
Exp Aging Res. 1980 Oct;6(5):463-73. doi: 10.1080/03610738008258381.
Research on aging in general and on cautiousness in adulthood in particular has been plagued by several problems including (a) drawing of samples from the extremes of the adult age range; (b) relying on single criterion variables; and (c) paucity of data on the psychometric properties of scales. In the present study, three measures of risk taking were administered to a sample ranging from 18-78 years old. Reliability estimates indicated that the Choice Dilemmas Questionnaire had low reliability, both absolutely and in comparison to the vocabulary Risk Test and the Risk Taking Questionnaire. Convergent validity analyses indicated that the Choice Dilemma Questionnaire was substantially correlated with the Risk Taking Questionnaire but not with the Vocabulary Risk Test. Age differences were found only on the Choice Dilemmas Questionnaire using dichotomous scoring. Results suggest that properties of the scale may, in part, account for observed age differences in risk taking scores on the Choice Dilemma Questionnaire. The currently popular notion that people become more cautious as they grow older was challenged and directions were provided for future research.
总体而言,关于衰老的研究,尤其是关于成年人谨慎程度的研究,一直受到几个问题的困扰,包括:(a) 从成年年龄范围的两端抽取样本;(b) 依赖单一标准变量;以及 (c) 关于量表心理测量特性的数据匮乏。在本研究中,对年龄在18至78岁之间的样本进行了三项冒险倾向测量。信度估计表明,与词汇风险测试和冒险倾向问卷相比,选择困境问卷的信度较低,无论是绝对信度还是相对信度。收敛效度分析表明,选择困境问卷与冒险倾向问卷有显著相关性,但与词汇风险测试没有相关性。仅在使用二分法计分的选择困境问卷上发现了年龄差异。结果表明,量表的特性可能在一定程度上解释了在选择困境问卷上观察到的冒险倾向得分的年龄差异。目前流行的观点认为,随着年龄的增长,人们会变得更加谨慎,这一观点受到了挑战,并为未来的研究提供了方向。