Axelson O, Sundell L, Andersson K, Edling C, Hogstedt C, Kling H
Scand J Work Environ Health. 1980 Mar;6(1):73-9. doi: 10.5271/sjweh.2631.
An earlier cohort study of Swedish railroad workers indicated a possible relationship between exposure to herbicides and an increased overall tumor morbidity and mortality. The cohort of 348 individuals has now been followed through October 1978. In this updated analysis of the causes of death among railroad workers, the observed number of tumor deaths was higher than expected, especially among individuals exposed in the earlier years of the study to both amitrol and phenoxy acids. However, the excess tumor mortality among persons exposed to amitrol became more moderate, and the earlier, slightly increased tumor mortality among people exposed to phenoxy acids more pronounced. No specific type of tumor predominated although there were three stomach cancers and three lung cancers. The result of the previous analysis of deaths among these railroad workers has been confirmed as to an excess of tumors, but the aspects of causal relationships to specific agents remain rather unclear, especially since workers exposed to a combination of amitrol and phenoxy acids seem to be the most seriously affected. However, the result, being in agreement with animal data and other epidemiologic studies, suggests a need for the careful handling of amitrol and phenoxy acids as increasingly suspicious carcinogens.
一项针对瑞典铁路工人的早期队列研究表明,接触除草剂与总体肿瘤发病率和死亡率增加之间可能存在关联。该队列中的348名个体现已随访至1978年10月。在对铁路工人死亡原因的此次更新分析中,观察到的肿瘤死亡人数高于预期,尤其是在研究早期接触过杀草强和苯氧基酸的个体中。然而,接触杀草强人群中过高的肿瘤死亡率变得较为缓和,而接触苯氧基酸人群中早期略有增加的肿瘤死亡率则更为明显。尽管有3例胃癌和3例肺癌,但没有哪种特定类型的肿瘤占主导。这些铁路工人先前死亡分析的结果已被证明确实存在肿瘤过多的情况,但与特定因素的因果关系方面仍相当不明确,尤其是因为接触杀草强和苯氧基酸组合的工人似乎受影响最严重。然而,该结果与动物数据及其他流行病学研究一致,表明有必要将杀草强和苯氧基酸作为越来越可疑的致癌物进行谨慎处理。