Cooper R A
Health Policy Institute, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee 53226, USA.
JAMA. 1995 Nov 15;274(19):1534-43.
Physician supply and demand for the period extending to 2020 were assessed from three perspectives: physician utilization in group- and staff-model health maintenance organizations, physician distribution, and the future supply of nonphysician clinicians. The national norm for physician demand in 1993 was estimated to be 205 per 100,000 population. Demand is projected to increase 18% by 2020, because of both an expansion in beneficial services and a reduction in physician work effort. Supply initially will increase more rapidly, resulting in a surplus of 31,000 physicians (5% of patient care physicians) in the year 2000 and increasing to 62,000 physicians (8%) in 2010, after which the gap will narrow. Similar results were obtained when previous studies that had projected surpluses of 73,000 to 165,000 physicians (15% to 30%) in the year 2000 were reevaluated. However, physician distribution is not homogeneous, and the number of physicians per capita currently varies by more than twofold among states. Relative to the national norm, surpluses already exist in some states and shortages in others. In addition, the supply of nonphysician clinicians with independent practice authority is increasing. Their numbers are projected to double by 2010, equaling 60% of the number of patient care physicians. Measured as physician equivalents, their growth will equal the growth in physician supply. Thus, in terms of physicians alone, there is no evidence of a major impending national surplus. Local surpluses will be influenced principally by how physicians distribute themselves geographically. The major determinant of overall physician surpluses in the future will be the extent to which patients continue to seek physicians for services that also will be offered by an expanded workforce of nonphysician clinicians. Policy is needed that encompasses the universe of clinicians who will be providing care to patients in the next century.
从三个角度评估了截至2020年期间的医生供需情况:团体模式和员工模式健康维护组织中的医生利用率、医生分布以及非医生临床医生的未来供应。1993年全国医生需求的标准估计为每10万人中有205名医生。预计到2020年需求将增长18%,这是由于有益服务的扩展和医生工作负担的减轻。供应最初将增长得更快,导致2000年有31000名医生过剩(占提供患者护理的医生的5%),到2010年增加到62000名医生过剩(8%),此后差距将缩小。当对先前预测2000年有73000至165000名医生过剩(15%至30%)的研究进行重新评估时,得到了类似的结果。然而,医生分布并不均匀,目前各州人均医生数量相差两倍多。相对于全国标准,一些州已经出现过剩,而另一些州则存在短缺。此外,具有独立执业权的非医生临床医生的供应正在增加。预计到2010年他们的数量将翻倍,相当于提供患者护理的医生数量的60%。以医生当量衡量,他们的增长将与医生供应的增长相当。因此,仅就医生而言,没有证据表明即将出现全国性的严重过剩。局部过剩将主要受医生地理分布方式的影响。未来医生总体过剩的主要决定因素将是患者继续寻求医生提供非医生临床医生扩大后的劳动力队伍也将提供的服务的程度。需要制定涵盖下个世纪将为患者提供护理的所有临床医生的政策。