Morlet N, Young S, Naidoo D, Fong T, Coroneo M T
Department of Ophthalmology, Prince of Wales Hospital, University of New South Wales, Australia.
Br J Ophthalmol. 1995 Aug;79(8):753-5. doi: 10.1136/bjo.79.8.753.
It was previously found that high dose intravitreal ganciclovir provided superior treatment of cytomegalovirus retinitis compared with intravenous treatment. This study examined the stability and solubility of the ganciclovir solution to determine the shelf life of prepared solution, and compared the cost of intravitreal with intravenous therapy.
For the solubility studies high performance liquid chromatography was used to determine the ganciclovir concentration in various solutions. Measurements were taken of freshly made 20 mg/ml solution, the same solution stored at room temperature or frozen for 10, 17, and 24 days, after the solution was filtered, and after it was heated at 56 degrees C. For the cost comparison analysis the cost of 22 patients treated exclusively with intravitreal high dose ganciclovir was compared with cost estimates for the same patients treated with a standard intravenous therapy regimen over the same time.
There was little variation in the concentration of ganciclovir regardless of the storage conditions, suggesting that the 20 mg/ml solution was very stable. The heating and filtering experiments suggest that maximum solubility was achieved both in the freshly prepared and thawed frozen stored solution. The total cost of the intravitreal treatment was Aus $172,435 and the estimate of intravenous treatment was Aus $490,521. This represents a total saving of $318,086 (65%), or $14,458 per patient. The average number of weeks of treatment for each patient was 27.9 (613 weeks/22 patients), so the saving per patient per year was $29,946.
High dose intravitreal ganciclovir therapy may be administered in a very cost effective way, which along with its acceptability, safety, and clinical efficacy make it an attractive method of treatment of CMV retinitis.
先前发现,与静脉治疗相比,高剂量玻璃体内注射更昔洛韦治疗巨细胞病毒性视网膜炎效果更佳。本研究检测了更昔洛韦溶液的稳定性和溶解性,以确定配制溶液的保质期,并比较了玻璃体内注射疗法与静脉疗法的成本。
在溶解性研究中,采用高效液相色谱法测定不同溶液中的更昔洛韦浓度。对新配制的20mg/ml溶液、在室温下储存或冷冻10、17和24天的同一溶液、过滤后的溶液以及在56℃加热后的溶液进行测量。在成本比较分析中,将22例仅接受高剂量玻璃体内注射更昔洛韦治疗的患者的成本与同一时间内接受标准静脉治疗方案的相同患者的成本估算进行比较。
无论储存条件如何,更昔洛韦的浓度几乎没有变化,这表明20mg/ml溶液非常稳定。加热和过滤实验表明,新配制的溶液和冷冻后解冻的溶液均达到了最大溶解度。玻璃体内注射治疗的总成本为172,435澳元,静脉治疗的估算成本为490,521澳元。这意味着总共节省了318,086澳元(65%),即每位患者节省14,458澳元。每位患者的平均治疗周数为27.9周(613周/22例患者),因此每位患者每年节省29,946澳元。
高剂量玻璃体内注射更昔洛韦疗法可能具有很高的成本效益,再加上其可接受性、安全性和临床疗效,使其成为治疗巨细胞病毒性视网膜炎的一种有吸引力的方法。