Kiyono K, Sone S, Sakai F, Kawai T, Karakida O, Kasuga T, Hirano H, Matsumoto T
Department of Radiology, Shinshu University School of Medicine.
Nihon Igaku Hoshasen Gakkai Zasshi. 1994 Nov 25;54(13):1237-44.
We compared the ability of standard film-screen chest radiographs to detect simulated pulmonary nodules. The radiographs were taken with different X-ray filters and tube voltages. Detection capability was analyzed utilizing receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves formed from the interpretation of six readers. Nodule detection was slightly better in images obtained with a tube voltage of 135 kVp than with one of 100 kVp (not statistically significant). Approximately equal detection performance was shown by a conventional film-screen system and FCR with three X-ray filter sets: a copper filter backed by aluminium, a tungsten filter backed by yttrium and aluminium, and a lead filter backed by yttrium and aluminium. Results showed less X-ray exposure with the two latter filter sets. Unenhanced FCR images taken with approximately the same X-ray exposure as conventional radiographs showed nearly equal ability to detect the simulated nodules.
我们比较了标准屏-片胸部X线片检测模拟肺结节的能力。这些X线片是在不同的X线滤过器和管电压条件下拍摄的。利用由六位阅片者的判读结果形成的受试者操作特征(ROC)曲线分析检测能力。在管电压为135 kVp时获得的图像中,结节检测略优于管电压为100 kVp时的图像(无统计学意义)。传统屏-片系统和配备三种X线滤过器组合的FCR(铜滤过器后接铝、钨滤过器后接钇和铝、铅滤过器后接钇和铝)表现出大致相同的检测性能。结果显示,后两种滤过器组合的X线照射量较少。与传统X线片X线照射量大致相同情况下拍摄的未增强FCR图像,在检测模拟结节方面表现出几乎相同的能力。