Hart Y M, Shorvon S D
Institute of Neurology, Queen Square, London, United Kingdom.
Epilepsy Res. 1995 May;21(1):51-8. doi: 10.1016/0920-1211(95)00008-x.
The medical care received by an unselected population of patients with epilepsy identified from the lists of 119 general practitioners in the UK was evaluated and compared with established standards. The study was carried out by questionnaire distributed to the patients and their general practitioners. Information was collected about hospital referral patterns, the doctor responsible for follow-up, investigations performed, attendances at Accident and Emergency (A&E) departments, hospital admissions, medication, and the information supplied to patients. Eighty-one per cent of patients had been referred to a hospital outpatient clinic, and 28% were under continuing hospital follow-up. Only 6% had been seen in a specialist epilepsy clinic. The majority had had an electroencephalogram (EEG), but less than half a CT scan. Forty-three per cent had attended an A&E department on account of epilepsy, and 47% had required hospital admission. Sixty-five per cent of patients were on monotherapy, mostly phenytoin, carbamazepine or sodium valproate: a significant proportion also took phenobarbitone. Except for the issues of free prescriptions and driving, patients could remember being given little information about epilepsy, and this was the most common source of dissatisfaction. The study suggests many accepted recommendations about the care of people with epilepsy are not followed, with hospital referral patterns, a shortage of specialists epilepsy clinics, and lack of patient information being areas of concern.
对从英国119名全科医生名单中确定的未经挑选的癫痫患者群体所接受的医疗护理进行了评估,并与既定标准进行了比较。该研究通过向患者及其全科医生发放问卷来进行。收集了有关医院转诊模式、负责随访的医生、进行的检查、在急诊部门的就诊情况、住院情况、用药情况以及提供给患者的信息等方面的信息。81%的患者被转诊至医院门诊诊所,28%的患者正在接受医院的持续随访。只有6%的患者在癫痫专科门诊就诊过。大多数患者进行过脑电图(EEG)检查,但进行CT扫描的不到一半。43%的患者因癫痫到急诊部门就诊,47%的患者需要住院治疗。65%的患者采用单一疗法,主要是苯妥英、卡马西平或丙戊酸钠:相当一部分患者还服用苯巴比妥。除了免费处方和驾驶问题外,患者记得关于癫痫的信息很少,这是最常见的不满来源。该研究表明,许多关于癫痫患者护理的公认建议未得到遵循,医院转诊模式、癫痫专科门诊短缺以及患者信息缺乏是令人担忧的领域。