Deruty R, Pelissou-Guyotat I, Amat D, Mottolese C, Bascoulergue Y, Turjman F, Gerard J P
Department of Neurosurgery, Hopital Neurologique et Neurochirurgical, Lyon, France.
Neurol Res. 1995 Jun;17(3):169-77. doi: 10.1080/01616412.1995.11740307.
A series of 67 patients treated for cerebral AVM with a multidisciplinary approach is reported. The malformations were classified after the Spetzler Grading Scale, with 67% low-grade and 33% high-grade AVMs. Three modes of treatment were used: surgical resection, endovascular embolization, and radiosurgery (linear accelerator technique). The actual treatment was: surgical resection alone (25% of cases), embolization plus resection (25% of cases), embolization alone (21%) and radiosurgery (30%) either alone (12%), or after incomplete embolization (15%) or after incomplete resection (3%). The clinical outcome was evaluated in terms of deterioration due to treatment. The treatment was responsible for a deterioration in 28% of all patients, either minor deterioration (19%) neurological deficit (4%), or death (4%). All complications of surgical resection (17% of all operated cases) and of radiosurgery (10% of irradiated cases) remained minor. None was haemodynamic-related. After endovascular embolization, a deterioration occurred in 25% of all embolized cases (minor 13%, neurological deficit 5% and death 8%). These complications occurring after embolization were haemodynamic related: ischaemia and haemorrhage (50% for each mechanism). Haemorrhage occurred either during or some days after the embolization procedure. The angiographic eradication rate was: 80% overall, 91% after resection (with or without previous embolization), 87% after radiosurgery (alone or after other techniques), and 10% after embolization alone. The discussion reviews in the literature the general evolution of the management of cerebral AVMs, with successive application of first surgical resection, the embolization and lastly radiosurgery.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
报告了一系列采用多学科方法治疗的67例脑动静脉畸形(AVM)患者。根据斯佩茨勒分级量表对畸形进行分类,低级别AVM占67%,高级别AVM占33%。采用了三种治疗方式:手术切除、血管内栓塞和放射外科(直线加速器技术)。实际治疗情况为:单纯手术切除(25%的病例)、栓塞加切除(25%的病例)、单纯栓塞(21%)以及放射外科治疗(30%),其中放射外科单独治疗(12%)、不完全栓塞后(15%)或不完全切除后(3%)。根据治疗导致的病情恶化情况评估临床结果。治疗导致28%的患者病情恶化,包括轻度恶化(19%)、神经功能缺损(4%)或死亡(4%)。手术切除(所有手术病例的17%)和放射外科治疗(照射病例的10%)的所有并发症均较轻微。均与血流动力学无关。血管内栓塞后,所有栓塞病例中有25%出现病情恶化(轻度13%、神经功能缺损5%和死亡8%)。栓塞后出现的这些并发症与血流动力学有关:缺血和出血(每种机制各占50%)。出血发生在栓塞过程中或栓塞后数天。血管造影根除率为:总体80%,切除后(无论是否先前进行过栓塞)为91%,放射外科治疗后(单独或其他技术后)为87%,单纯栓塞后为10%。讨论回顾了文献中脑AVM治疗的总体进展,依次应用了首先手术切除、栓塞,最后是放射外科治疗。(摘要截取自250字)