Gnudi S, Fini M, Zati A, Giavaresi G, Giardino R, Zucchini C, Biagini G
Department of Internal Medicine, Istituti Ortopedici Rizzoli, Bologna.
Boll Soc Ital Biol Sper. 1995 Mar-Apr;71(3-4):111-9.
The post-ovariectomy osteoporotic rat model is widely used to mimic post menopausal human osteoporosis and to test the efficacy of the therapies used in its treatment An experimental study was performed in order to improve the reliability of bone mineral density (BMD) measurements by correcting also the relocation error. In addition, a BMD map of the whole femur was carried out to detect the areas of uniform density, where the reliability of measuring was improved. Right femurs were taken from 5 Sprague Dawley female rats, 10 months old, and tested every 2 mm from the supracondylar line to the peritrochanteric line (6 scans for each site). Repositioning error was tested for each site of measurement, and measurements done by 3 different operators in a double blind test were compared. At site 4 and 24 (where the differences are high) and site 10 (where the differences of BMD are low) the coefficient of variability (CV) was calculated repositioning the bone after each measurement scan for a total of 6 scans. The CV at sites 4 and 24 were significantly higher than at site 10 (p < 0.05). In our opinion, the bone segment between 8 and 14 mm from the supracondylar line is that which presents the highest homogeneity and where it is preferable to perform the measurements in order to obtain the maximum effect of the method (improvement of precision of about 30%) in comparison with the other femur sites tested.
卵巢切除术后骨质疏松大鼠模型被广泛用于模拟绝经后人类骨质疏松症,并测试其治疗方法的疗效。为了通过校正重新定位误差来提高骨密度(BMD)测量的可靠性,进行了一项实验研究。此外,还绘制了整个股骨的BMD图,以检测密度均匀的区域,在这些区域测量的可靠性得到了提高。从5只10个月大的Sprague Dawley雌性大鼠身上取出右股骨,从髁上线到转子周围线每隔2毫米进行测试(每个部位进行6次扫描)。对每个测量部位的重新定位误差进行了测试,并比较了3名不同操作人员在双盲测试中所做的测量。在第4和24部位(差异较大)以及第10部位(BMD差异较小),在每次测量扫描后重新定位骨骼,共进行6次扫描,计算变异系数(CV)。第4和24部位的CV显著高于第10部位(p < 0.05)。我们认为,从髁上线起8至14毫米之间的骨段具有最高的同质性,与测试的其他股骨部位相比,在此处进行测量更可取,以便获得该方法的最大效果(精度提高约30%)。