Breslau N, Davis G C, Andreski P
Department of Psychiatry, Henry Ford Health Sciences Center, Detroit, MI 48202.
Am J Psychiatry. 1995 Apr;152(4):529-35. doi: 10.1176/ajp.152.4.529.
The authors previously identified suspected risk factors for traumatic events related to posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) on the basis of data gathered retrospectively. In this study, they tested that model prospectively.
A random sample of 1,200 persons was drawn from all 21- to 30-year-old members of a large health maintenance organization. In 1989, 1,007 of these persons were interviewed, and suspected risk factors were measured. In 1992, 979 were reinterviewed, and the 3-year incidence of exposure to traumatic events was ascertained.
Nineteen percent of the sample reported traumatic events during the 3-year follow-up. A history of past exposure to traumatic events signaled an increase in the liability to exposure during follow-up, independent of suspected risk factors. Two predictors of exposure, neuroticism and extroversion, identified retrospectively, also predicted exposure prospectively. The odds for exposure among males and persons with less than a college education were marginally significant. Early misconduct and a family history of psychiatric disorder-predictors of exposure in the retrospective data-were not significant predictors at 3-year follow-up. Blacks had a higher incidence of exposure during follow-up than whites. An exploratory reanalysis suggested that the discrepancy between the retrospective and prospective results may be explained by the inclusion of childhood exposure in the lifetime retrospective inquiry.
The assumption that PTSD-related traumatic events are random phenomena was unsupported. Among young adults, those with less education, blacks, and those with high neuroticism and extroversion scores are more likely than others to be exposed to traumatic events and are thus at greater risk for PTSD.
作者先前基于回顾性收集的数据确定了与创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)相关的创伤事件的疑似风险因素。在本研究中,他们对该模型进行了前瞻性测试。
从一个大型健康维护组织的所有21至30岁成员中随机抽取1200人作为样本。1989年,对其中1007人进行了访谈,并测量了疑似风险因素。1992年,对979人进行了再次访谈,并确定了3年内创伤事件暴露的发生率。
19%的样本报告在3年随访期间发生了创伤事件。既往有创伤事件暴露史表明随访期间暴露易感性增加,与疑似风险因素无关。回顾性确定的两个暴露预测因素,神经质和外向性,也前瞻性地预测了暴露情况。男性和未受过大学教育者的暴露几率略具显著性。早期行为不端和精神疾病家族史(回顾性数据中的暴露预测因素)在3年随访时不是显著的预测因素。黑人在随访期间的暴露发生率高于白人。一项探索性重新分析表明,回顾性和前瞻性结果之间的差异可能是由于在终生回顾性调查中纳入了童年暴露。
与PTSD相关的创伤事件是随机现象这一假设未得到支持。在年轻人中,受教育程度较低者、黑人以及神经质和外向性得分较高者比其他人更有可能暴露于创伤事件,因此患PTSD的风险更大。