Kudrow L, Kudrow D B, Sandweiss J H
California Medical Clinic for Headache, Encino 91436, USA.
Headache. 1995 Feb;35(2):79-82. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4610.1995.hed3502079.x.
In a noncontrolled study, 23 migraine headache patients were treated with intranasal instillation of 0.4 mL of a 4% lidocaine solution during attacks of varying intensities. Evaluated were pretreatment and posttreatment changes in pain intensity, nausea, and side effects. Posttreatment intensity ratings significantly improved over pretreatment ratings, as determined by a Sandler A analysis (0.077; P < .0005). Migraine attacks were aborted in 12 of 23 patients, of which 8 were completely relieved within 5 minutes. In no case did an aborted attack return to more than a dull level within 24 hours, as determined by follow-up telephone calls. A successful response of migraine attacks to lidocaine treatment was more apt to occur in patients having migraine solely, when compared to migraine patients who also had daily dull headaches; the difference was not significant. Unilateral attacks, however, were significantly more treatment-responsive when compared to bilateral attacks (X2 = 3.85; P = .05). Nausea, associated with migraine attacks in 6 of 12 responders, was similarly aborted by lidocaine in 5 of 6 patients. Other side effects included mild nasal and eye burning of short duration (seconds), and oropharyngeal numbness of approximately 20 minutes' duration. Despite the abrupt and absolute relief of migraine attacks afforded by lidocaine in most of our study patients, its level of efficacy awaits results of double-blind, placebo-controlled studies. Our findings raise new questions regarding the differential pathogenesis of migraine and cluster headache attacks.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
在一项非对照研究中,23名偏头痛患者在发作强度各异时接受了鼻内滴注0.4毫升4%利多卡因溶液的治疗。评估了治疗前后疼痛强度、恶心及副作用的变化。通过桑德勒A分析确定,治疗后强度评分显著优于治疗前评分(0.077;P <.0005)。23名患者中有12名偏头痛发作中止,其中8名在5分钟内完全缓解。通过随访电话确定,在任何情况下,中止发作的患者在24小时内均未恢复至超过隐痛水平。与同时患有每日隐痛性头痛的偏头痛患者相比,单纯性偏头痛患者对利多卡因治疗偏头痛发作的成功反应更易出现;差异不显著。然而,与双侧发作相比,单侧发作对治疗的反应明显更显著(X2 = 3.85;P =.05)。12名有反应患者中有6名偏头痛发作伴有恶心,其中5名患者的恶心同样被利多卡因中止。其他副作用包括持续时间较短(数秒)的轻度鼻内和眼部烧灼感,以及持续约20分钟的口咽麻木感。尽管在我们的大多数研究患者中,利多卡因能迅速且完全缓解偏头痛发作,但其疗效水平仍有待双盲、安慰剂对照研究的结果。我们的研究结果引发了关于偏头痛和丛集性头痛发作不同发病机制的新问题。(摘要截短至250字)