Samuelian J C, Billardon M, Guillou N
Service de Psychiatrie, CHU La Timone, Marseille.
Encephale. 1995 Mar-Apr;21(2):147-53.
The aim of this randomized, double-blind, multicentric study was to assess and compare cognitive impairment in patients treated with either lorazepam or hydroxyzine, for generalized anxiety. Only non depressed patients were selected according to MADRS criteria. The cognitive assessment was performed with the BEC 96 rating scale, the intensity of anxiety symptoms was evaluated through the Hamilton-anxiety and Covi scales. The level of relation, mood and sedation was assessed for each item with a visual analog scale (VAS). The patient's and investigator's opinion on the global efficiency of the treatment were also evaluated on VAS. After an 8-day wash-out period under placebo, the treatment was given in a double-blind way for 28 days: either hydroxyzine 25 mg at a daily dosage of 100 mg t.i.d. (25 mg - 25 mg - 50 mg), or lorazepam 1 mg at a daily dosage of 4 mg t.i.d. (1 mg - 1 mg - 2 mg). The results were as follows: after the 28-day treatment period, patients showed at the BEC 96 a cognitive improvement in both groups, but the improvement in the hydroxyzine group was significantly higher. Furthermore, the improvement appeared more quickly in the hydroxyzine group. The Hamilton-anxiety and Covi scales showed an improvement in the anxiety level in both groups with no significant difference. The visual analog scales assessing relation, mood and sedation improved in both groups as well as the patient's and investigator's opinion. The five assessments all showed a significant by higher improvement in the hydroxyzine group.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
这项随机、双盲、多中心研究的目的是评估和比较接受劳拉西泮或羟嗪治疗广泛性焦虑症患者的认知障碍情况。仅根据蒙哥马利-艾森伯格抑郁量表(MADRS)标准选择非抑郁患者。使用BEC 96评定量表进行认知评估,通过汉密尔顿焦虑量表和科维量表评估焦虑症状的强度。用视觉模拟量表(VAS)对每个项目的关系、情绪和镇静水平进行评估。还通过VAS评估患者和研究者对治疗总体疗效的看法。在安慰剂洗脱期8天后,以双盲方式给药28天:要么给予羟嗪25毫克,每日剂量100毫克,每日三次(25毫克 - 25毫克 - 50毫克),要么给予劳拉西泮1毫克,每日剂量4毫克,每日三次(1毫克 - 1毫克 - 2毫克)。结果如下:在28天治疗期后,两组患者在BEC 96量表上均显示出认知改善,但羟嗪组的改善明显更高。此外,羟嗪组的改善出现得更快。汉密尔顿焦虑量表和科维量表显示两组焦虑水平均有改善,无显著差异。评估关系、情绪和镇静的视觉模拟量表以及患者和研究者的看法在两组中也都有所改善。五项评估均显示羟嗪组的改善明显更高。(摘要截断于250字)