Bates D W, Boyle D L, Vander Vliet M B, Schneider J, Leape L
Department of Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 1995 Apr;10(4):199-205. doi: 10.1007/BF02600255.
To evaluate the frequency of medication errors using a multidisciplinary approach, to classify these errors by type, and to determine how often medication errors are associated with adverse drug events (ADEs) and potential ADEs.
Medication errors were detected using self-report by pharmacists, nurse review of all patient charts, and review of all medication sheets. Incidents that were thought to represent ADEs or potential ADEs were identified through spontaneous reporting from nursing or pharmacy personnel, solicited reporting from nurses, and daily chart review by the study nurse. Incidents were subsequently classified by two independent reviewers as ADEs or potential ADEs.
Three medical units at an urban tertiary care hospital.
A cohort of 379 consecutive admissions during a 51-day period (1,704 patient-days).
None.
Over the study period, 10,070 medication orders were written, and 530 medications errors were identified (5.3 errors/100 orders), for a mean of 0.3 medication errors per patient-day, or 1.4 per admission. Of the medication errors, 53% involved at least one missing dose of a medication; 15% involved other dose errors, 8% frequency errors, and 5% route errors. During the same period, 25 ADEs and 35 potential ADEs were found. Of the 25 ADEs, five (20%) were associated with medication errors; all were judged preventable. Thus, five of 530 medication errors (0.9%) resulted in ADEs. Physician computer order entry could have prevented 84% of non-missing dose medication errors, 86% of potential ADEs, and 60% of preventable ADEs.
Medication errors are common, although relatively few result in ADEs. However, those that do are preventable, many through physician computer order entry.
采用多学科方法评估用药错误的发生率,按类型对这些错误进行分类,并确定用药错误与药物不良事件(ADEs)和潜在药物不良事件相关的频率。
通过药剂师自我报告、护士对所有患者病历的审查以及对所有用药单的审查来检测用药错误。通过护理或药房人员的自发报告、护士的主动报告以及研究护士的每日病历审查来识别被认为代表药物不良事件或潜在药物不良事件的事件。随后由两名独立审查员将事件分类为药物不良事件或潜在药物不良事件。
一家城市三级护理医院的三个医疗单元。
在51天期间连续收治的379例患者(1704个患者日)。
无。
在研究期间,共开出10070份用药医嘱,识别出530例用药错误(每100份医嘱中有5.3例错误),平均每位患者日有0.3例用药错误,每次入院有1.4例。在用药错误中,53%涉及至少一次漏服药物;15%涉及其他剂量错误,8%为频率错误,5%为给药途径错误。在同一时期,发现25例药物不良事件和35例潜在药物不良事件。在25例药物不良事件中,5例(20%)与用药错误相关;所有这些都被判定为可预防的。因此,530例用药错误中有5例(0.9%)导致了药物不良事件。医生计算机医嘱录入可预防84%的非漏服药物用药错误、86%的潜在药物不良事件以及60%的可预防药物不良事件。
用药错误很常见,尽管相对较少导致药物不良事件。然而,那些导致药物不良事件的是可预防的,许多可通过医生计算机医嘱录入来预防。