Karasu T B
Department of Psychiatry, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, New York 10461.
Am J Psychother. 1994 Fall;48(4):581-99. doi: 10.1176/appi.psychotherapy.1994.48.4.581.
The author proposes an integrative model of psychopathology in light of the contemporary need to bridge diverse ideological frameworks. This model has its major foundations in drive, ego, object relations, and self psychoanalytic perspectives as they impact upon interactional patterns of infancy. The chronology of these theoretical orientations is presented as parallel to a changing focus upon different successive stages in the course of individual development. The longstanding controversy between conflict and deficit theories, which undergirds the various schools of thought, is addressed: a developmental orientation is offered as the overriding conceptual connection between them. Conflict and deficit phenomena are regarded as intertwined and not incompatible: Unconscious drives, desires and wishes, ego defenses, and compromise formations as well as object relationship deficiencies and structural voids and defects in the self are combined to encompass a broad spectrum of psychopathology and its sources: the above intrapsychic and interpersonal factors are interfaced with significant reciprocal dyadic (mother/child) and triadic (father/mother/child) influences upon ongoing maturational processes. For heuristic purposes, a fourfold matrix--dyadic deficit, dyadic conflict, triadic deficit, and triadic conflict--is delineated. Clinical characteristics and developmental precursors of each of the four prototypes, especially with regard to early relational events, are examined.
鉴于当前弥合不同思想框架的需求,作者提出了一种精神病理学的综合模型。该模型主要基于驱力、自我、客体关系和自体精神分析视角,因为它们影响着婴儿期的互动模式。这些理论取向的时间顺序与个体发展过程中对不同连续阶段不断变化的关注并行呈现。文中探讨了支撑各种思想流派的冲突理论和缺陷理论之间长期存在的争议:提出一种发展取向作为它们之间首要的概念联系。冲突和缺陷现象被视为相互交织且并非不相容:无意识驱力、欲望和愿望、自我防御、妥协形成以及客体关系缺陷、自体结构的空隙和缺陷相结合,涵盖了广泛的精神病理学及其根源:上述心理内部和人际因素与对持续成熟过程有重要影响的二元(母婴)和三元(父/母/子)相互作用相互关联。为便于启发思考,划定了一个四重矩阵——二元缺陷、二元冲突、三元缺陷和三元冲突。研究了这四种原型各自的临床特征和发展先兆,尤其是关于早期关系事件方面。