Simes R J, Topol E J, Holmes D R, White H D, Rutsch W R, Vahanian A, Simoons M L, Morris D, Betriu A, Califf R M
National Health Medical Research Council Clinical Trials Centre, University of Sydney, Australia.
Circulation. 1995 Apr 1;91(7):1923-8. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.91.7.1923.
The Global Utilization of Streptokinase and TPA for Occluded Coronary Arteries (GUSTO-I) trial was designed to test whether thrombolytic strategies achieving more complete, early, sustained coronary artery patency would lead to further reductions in mortality in patients with acute myocardial infarction. An angiographic substudy within GUSTO-I provided a unique opportunity to examine the relation between mortality and degrees of patency among the regimens.
Four thrombolytic strategies were compared in 41,021 patients in GUSTO-I: streptokinase with subcutaneous or intravenous heparin, accelerated tissue plasminogen activator (TPA) with intravenous heparin, and combination streptokinase plus TPA with intravenous heparin. Accelerated TPA was associated with lower 30-day mortality (6.3%) than the other strategies (7.2%, 7.4%, and 7.0%, respectively). Among the 1210 patients in the angiographic substudy randomized to angiography 90 minutes after starting treatment, there was improved patency, particularly Thrombolysis in Myocardial Infarction (TIMI) grade 3 flow, with accelerated TPA over the other regimens (P < .0001). Coronary artery perfusion (TIMI grade 3) at 90 minutes was also a significant predictor of 30-day survival (P < .01). To determine whether differences in mortality among the four strategies matched differences in 90-minute patency, a model was developed for predicting mortality differences in the main trial from the angiographic substudy. The model assumed that any differences in treatment effects on 30-day mortality were mediated through differences in 90-minute patency for the four treatments. The predicted rates were then compared with observed mortality rates of the remaining patients in the main trial for each treatment group. The predicted and observed 30-day mortality rates of the four treatments were streptokinase with subcutaneous heparin, 7.46% versus 7.28%; streptokinase with intravenous heparin, 7.26% versus 7.39%; accelerated TPA, 6.31% versus 6.37%; and streptokinase plus TPA, 6.98% versus 6.96%. The correlation between predicted and observed results was .97, and the proportion of squared error explained (R2) was .92.
The close relation between the predicted and observed 30-day mortality rates supports the concept that an important mechanism for improved survival with thrombolytic therapy is achievement of early, complete perfusion. The close match provides a strong biological explanation for the mortality differences seen in GUSTO-I and a sound rationale for the additional survival advantage of the accelerated TPA regimen. Irrespective of which treatment is used, early and complete restoration of infarct artery perfusion represents an essential goal of myocardial reperfusion therapy.
全球应用链激酶和组织型纤溶酶原激活剂治疗闭塞冠状动脉(GUSTO - I)试验旨在测试,实现更完全、早期、持续的冠状动脉通畅的溶栓策略是否会进一步降低急性心肌梗死患者的死亡率。GUSTO - I试验中的一项血管造影子研究提供了一个独特的机会,来研究各治疗方案中死亡率与通畅程度之间的关系。
GUSTO - I试验中,对41021例患者比较了四种溶栓策略:链激酶联合皮下或静脉肝素、加速组织型纤溶酶原激活剂(TPA)联合静脉肝素、链激酶加TPA联合静脉肝素。加速TPA治疗组30天死亡率(6.3%)低于其他治疗组(分别为7.2%、7.4%和7.0%)。在血管造影子研究的1210例患者中,随机分组后于治疗开始90分钟进行血管造影,结果显示,与其他治疗方案相比,加速TPA治疗组的血管通畅情况有所改善,尤其是心肌梗死溶栓(TIMI)3级血流(P <.0001)。90分钟时的冠状动脉灌注(TIMI 3级)也是30天生存率的重要预测指标(P <.01)。为了确定四种治疗策略之间的死亡率差异是否与90分钟时的血管通畅程度差异相匹配,建立了一个模型,用于根据血管造影子研究预测主要试验中的死亡率差异。该模型假设,四种治疗方案对30天死亡率的治疗效果差异是通过90分钟时血管通畅程度的差异介导的。然后将预测死亡率与主要试验中各治疗组其余患者的观察死亡率进行比较。四种治疗方案预测的和观察到的30天死亡率分别为:链激酶联合皮下肝素,7.46%对7.28%;链激酶联合静脉肝素,7.26%对7.39%;加速TPA,6.31%对6.37%;链激酶加TPA,6.98%对6.96%。预测结果与观察结果的相关性为0.97,误差平方解释比例(R2)为0.92。
预测的和观察到的30天死亡率之间的密切关系支持了这样一种观点,即溶栓治疗改善生存的一个重要机制是实现早期、完全灌注。这种紧密匹配为GUSTO - I试验中观察到的死亡率差异提供了强有力的生物学解释,也为加速TPA治疗方案额外的生存优势提供了合理依据。无论采用哪种治疗方法,梗死动脉灌注的早期和完全恢复都是心肌再灌注治疗的一个基本目标。