Gokli M A, Wood A J, Mourino A P, Farrington F H, Best A M
Department of Pediatric Dentistry, Medical College of Virginia-Virginia Commonwealth University.
ASDC J Dent Child. 1994 Jul-Aug;61(4):272-5.
This study investigates the acceptance of local anesthetic injection, utilizing hypnosis in twenty-nine children, ages four to thirteen years. Each subject was evaluated twice, once utilizing hypnosis before injection, and once without. A double blind research design was used to avoid effects of expectancy. Subjects in the study were videotaped during the procedure. Their behavior was rated independently by two pediatric dentists, using the North Carolina Behavior Rating Scale (NBRS). Transcutaneous pulse oximetry data were also recorded for each subject. The resulting data were evaluated for statistically significant differences between the two methods and for interrater reliability. Results showed no statistically significant differences in oxygen saturation due to hypnosis condition, order of treatment, sex, race, or age. Statistically significant differences were found in pulse rate and behavior, attributable to hypnosis condition and age, but not to sex, race, or order of treatment. Pulse rate decreased with hypnosis, as did crying. The hypnosis condition seemed to be more successful with younger children (four to six years old).
本研究调查了29名4至13岁儿童在局部麻醉注射时使用催眠的接受情况。每位受试者接受了两次评估,一次在注射前使用催眠,另一次不使用。采用双盲研究设计以避免期望效应。研究过程中对受试者进行了录像。两位儿科牙医使用北卡罗来纳行为评定量表(NBRS)对他们的行为进行独立评分。还记录了每位受试者的经皮脉搏血氧饱和度数据。对所得数据进行评估,以确定两种方法之间是否存在统计学上的显著差异以及评分者间的可靠性。结果显示,由于催眠状态、治疗顺序、性别、种族或年龄的不同,血氧饱和度没有统计学上的显著差异。在脉搏率和行为方面发现了统计学上的显著差异,这归因于催眠状态和年龄,而非性别、种族或治疗顺序。催眠时脉搏率下降,哭泣情况也有所减少。催眠状态似乎在年幼儿童(4至6岁)中更为成功。