Kunst A E, Mackenbach J P
Department of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Int J Epidemiol. 1994 Aug;23(4):742-50. doi: 10.1093/ije/23.4.742.
Previous international comparisons on the size of mortality differences associated with occupational status have relied on inequality indices with one or more limitations. This study reassesses the international pattern of inequalities in mortality using an inequality index devised recently.
Data on mortality by social class were obtained from longitudinal studies from seven countries. The data referred to men aged 35-64 years. The follow-up period was approximately 1971-1981. The size of mortality differences associated with occupational status was measured using a modification of the Relative Index of Inequality.
The smallest inequalities in mortality are observed for Norway and Denmark. Larger inequalities are observed for Sweden (compared to Norway circa 1.5 times as large), England and Wales (2 times), Finland (4-5 times) and France (6-8 times). Inequalities in a Dutch city, Rotterdam, are as large as in Danish and Swedish cities, and smaller than in Finnish and French cities. Results of sensitivity analyses suggest that probably only a small part of this international pattern can be attributed to differences between countries with respect to occupational classification.
The results of most previous international comparisons agree with the general pattern observed here. This simultaneous comparison of various countries shows that the frequently cited difference between Sweden, and England and Wales is small when viewed in a wider international context.
以往关于职业地位与死亡率差异大小的国际比较依赖于存在一个或多个局限性的不平等指数。本研究使用最近设计的不平等指数重新评估死亡率不平等的国际模式。
从七个国家的纵向研究中获取按社会阶层划分的死亡率数据。数据涉及35至64岁的男性。随访期约为1971年至1981年。使用不平等相对指数的一种修正方法来衡量与职业地位相关的死亡率差异大小。
挪威和丹麦的死亡率不平等最小。瑞典(与挪威相比约为其1.5倍)、英格兰和威尔士(2倍)、芬兰(4至5倍)和法国(6至8倍)的不平等较大。荷兰城市鹿特丹的不平等与丹麦和瑞典城市的一样大,且小于芬兰和法国城市的。敏感性分析结果表明,这种国际模式可能只有一小部分可归因于不同国家在职业分类方面的差异。
以往大多数国际比较的结果与这里观察到的总体模式一致。对各国的这种同时比较表明,在更广泛的国际背景下看,瑞典与英格兰和威尔士之间经常被提及的差异较小。