Thadani U, Ezekowitz M, Fenney L, Chiang Y K
University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center 73104.
Circulation. 1994 Aug;90(2):726-34. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.90.2.726.
Ranolazine modulates the metabolism of ischemic myocardial cells and improves the efficiency of oxygen use. This study was conducted to evaluate the antianginal and anti-ischemic effects and safety of different doses of ranolazine administered three times daily (tid) compared with placebo in patients with stable angina pectoris.
Patients with stable angina pectoris took part in the study. Previous antianginal drugs were discontinued under medical supervision. Three hundred nineteen patients received single-blind placebo for up to 18 days, and 318 stopped exercise because of angina of moderate severity, had evidence of myocardial ischemia (> or = 1-mm ST segment depression), and were randomized to one of four study groups in a double-blind manner: ranolazine 30 mg tid (n = 81), ranolazine 60 mg tid (n = 81), ranolazine 120 mg tid (n = 78), and placebo tid (n = 79). After the 4-week double-blind phase, symptom-limited exercise tests were repeated at 1 hour (peak test) and 8 hours (trough test) after the study medication was administered. In addition, patients kept an angina diary throughout the study and wore a Holter monitor for 48 hours. Total exercise duration at baseline (+/- SEM) was 5.9 +/- 0.2 minutes for the placebo group and 6.4 +/- 0.3, 5.9 +/- 0.3, and 6.6 +/- 0.2 minutes for the ranolazine 30-, 60-, and 120-mg groups, respectively (P = NS). After 4 weeks of double-blind therapy, compared with baseline values, at 1 hour after the study medication was administered (peak effect), total exercise duration (+/- SEM) increased by 0.45 +/- 0.2 minutes in the placebo group and by 0.3 +/- 0.2, 0.6 +/- 0.2, and 0.5 +/- 0.2 minutes in the ranolazine 30-, 60-, and 120-mg groups, respectively (placebo versus ranolazine, P = NS). Times to 1-mm ST segment depression at baseline were similar in the four groups and, after 4 weeks of therapy in each group, increased significantly by similar magnitudes at 1 hour after the administration of the medications. Similar changes were seen for the time to onset of angina. Eight hours after administration (trough effect), no differences in total exercise time or any other exercise variables were observed between the placebo and the ranolazine groups. Compared with the baseline values, the number of anginal attacks per week and the number and duration of ischemic episodes per 48 hours during Holter monitoring decreased significantly by similar magnitudes in the placebo and ranolazine groups.
Therapy with ranolazine 30, 60, and 120 mg tid was not superior to placebo. Our study does not support the published beneficial effects of similar doses of ranolazine on either myocardial ischemia or exercise performance or on anginal attacks during daily life in patients with angina pectoris.
雷诺嗪可调节缺血心肌细胞的代谢并提高氧利用效率。本研究旨在评估与安慰剂相比,每日三次(tid)服用不同剂量雷诺嗪对稳定型心绞痛患者的抗心绞痛、抗缺血作用及安全性。
稳定型心绞痛患者参与了本研究。先前的抗心绞痛药物在医学监督下停用。319例患者接受单盲安慰剂治疗长达18天,其中318例因中度心绞痛停止运动,有心肌缺血证据(ST段压低≥1mm),并以双盲方式随机分为四个研究组之一:雷诺嗪30mg tid(n = 81)、雷诺嗪60mg tid(n = 81)、雷诺嗪120mg tid(n = 78)和安慰剂tid(n = 79)。在4周的双盲期后,在给予研究药物后1小时(峰值试验)和8小时(谷值试验)重复症状限制性运动试验。此外,患者在整个研究过程中记录心绞痛日记,并佩戴动态心电图监测仪48小时。安慰剂组基线时的总运动持续时间(±SEM)为5.9±0.2分钟,雷诺嗪30mg、60mg和120mg组分别为6.4±0.3分钟、5.9±0.3分钟和6.6±0.2分钟(P =无显著性差异)。双盲治疗4周后,与基线值相比,在给予研究药物后1小时(峰值效应),安慰剂组的总运动持续时间(±SEM)增加了0.45±0.2分钟,雷诺嗪30mg、60mg和120mg组分别增加了0.3±0.2分钟、0.6±0.2分钟和0.5±0.2分钟(安慰剂与雷诺嗪相比,P =无显著性差异)。四组基线时ST段压低1mm的时间相似,且每组治疗4周后,给药后1小时均显著增加相似幅度。心绞痛发作时间也有类似变化。给药8小时后(谷值效应),安慰剂组和雷诺嗪组在总运动时间或任何其他运动变量方面未观察到差异。与基线值相比,安慰剂组和雷诺嗪组每周心绞痛发作次数以及动态心电图监测期间每48小时缺血发作的次数和持续时间均显著减少相似幅度。
每日三次服用30mg、60mg和120mg雷诺嗪的治疗效果并不优于安慰剂。我们的研究不支持已发表的关于相似剂量雷诺嗪对心绞痛患者心肌缺血、运动表现或日常生活中心绞痛发作有有益作用的观点。