Dawsey S M, Lewin K J, Liu F S, Wang G Q, Shen Q
Cancer Prevention Studies Branch, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, Maryland 20895.
Cancer. 1994 Apr 15;73(8):2027-37. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(19940415)73:8<2027::aid-cncr2820730803>3.0.co;2-3.
Linxian, China, has one of the highest rates of esophageal cancer in the world. Other authors have described high prevalences of histologic esophagitis, atrophy, and dysplasia in Linxian and have suggested that these findings may represent precancerous lesions in this population. In 1987, a new endoscopic survey allowed the authors to make an independent study of esophageal histology in Linxian.
There were 1567 satisfactory squamous esophageal biopsies available from 754 patients. These biopsies were classified as normal, atrophy, acanthosis, esophagitis, squamous dysplasia, or squamous cancer.
Classified by their worst diagnosis, 56.5% of the 754 patients had normal mucosa, 0.0% atrophy, 11.5% acanthosis, 4.6% esophagitis, 22.7% squamous dysplasia, and 4.6% squamous cancer.
The results show a different distribution of esophageal squamous diagnoses than has been reported previously from this population. The authors believe that the major reason for this discrepancy was differences in histologic criteria. In this survey, seemingly small differences in criteria could cause large differences in apparent disease prevalence; this was especially true for esophagitis. By the criteria used in this study, histologic esophagitis and atrophy are uncommon findings in Linxian, raising questions about their significance as precursor lesions of esophageal cancer in this population.
中国林县是世界上食管癌发病率最高的地区之一。其他作者曾描述过林县组织学食管炎、萎缩和发育异常的高患病率,并认为这些发现可能代表该人群的癌前病变。1987年,一项新的内镜检查使作者能够对林县的食管组织学进行独立研究。
从754例患者中获得了1567份满意的食管鳞状上皮活检标本。这些活检标本被分类为正常、萎缩、棘皮症、食管炎、鳞状上皮发育异常或鳞状细胞癌。
按最严重诊断分类,754例患者中56.5%黏膜正常,0.0%萎缩,11.5%棘皮症,4.6%食管炎,22.7%鳞状上皮发育异常,4.6%鳞状细胞癌。
结果显示食管鳞状上皮诊断的分布与该人群先前报道的不同。作者认为这种差异的主要原因是组织学标准的不同。在本次调查中,标准上看似微小的差异可能导致明显疾病患病率的巨大差异;食管炎尤其如此。按照本研究使用的标准,组织学食管炎和萎缩在林县并不常见,这引发了关于它们作为该人群食管癌前体病变的意义的疑问。