Tokunaga M, Land C E, Tokuoka S, Nishimori I, Soda M, Akiba S
Department of Epidemiologic Pathology, Radiation Effects Research Foundation, Hiroshima, Japan.
Radiat Res. 1994 May;138(2):209-23.
An incidence survey among atomic bomb survivors identified 807 breast cancer cases, and 20 second breast cancers. As in earlier surveys of the Life Span Study population, a strongly linear radiation dose response was found, with the highest dose-specific excess relative risk (ERR) among survivors under 20 years old at the time of the bombings. Sixty-eight of the cases were under 10 years old at exposure, strengthening earlier reports of a marked excess risk associated with exposure during infancy and childhood. A much lower, but marginally significant, dose response was seen among women exposed at 40 years and older. It was not possible, however, to discriminate statistically between age at exposure and age at observation for risk as the more important determinant of ERR per unit dose. A 13-fold ERR at 1 Sv was found for breast cancer occurring before age 35, compared to a 2-fold excess after age 35, among survivors exposed before age 20. This a posteriori finding, based on 27 exposed, known-dose, early-onset cases, suggests the possible existence of a susceptible genetic subgroup. Further studies, involving family histories of cancer and investigations at the molecular level, are suggested to determine whether such a subgroup exists.
一项针对原子弹幸存者的发病率调查共识别出807例乳腺癌病例以及20例二次患乳腺癌病例。与早期对寿命研究人群的调查一样,发现了强烈的线性辐射剂量反应,在爆炸发生时年龄在20岁以下的幸存者中,剂量特异性超额相对风险(ERR)最高。其中68例在暴露时年龄在10岁以下,这强化了早期关于婴儿期和儿童期暴露会带来显著超额风险的报告。在40岁及以上暴露的女性中,观察到的剂量反应要低得多,但仍具有微弱的显著性。然而,由于暴露年龄和观察年龄作为每单位剂量ERR的更重要决定因素,在统计学上无法区分两者对风险的影响。在20岁之前暴露的幸存者中,35岁之前发生的乳腺癌在1 Sv时的ERR为13倍,而35岁之后为2倍。这一基于27例已知剂量的暴露早发病例的事后发现,表明可能存在一个易感基因亚组。建议进行进一步研究,包括癌症家族史调查和分子水平研究,以确定是否存在这样一个亚组。