Defrere J, Franckart A
Clinique Sainte-Rosalie, Liege, Belgium.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1994 Jun(303):56-66.
A study of 70 arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions with nonaugmented human freeze-dried fascia lata grafts is reported. The overall results are based on subjective, objective, and radiologic examinations as well as second-look arthroscopies at the one-year, four-year, and five-year follow-up evaluations. The average follow-up time was 4.5 years (range, two to seven years). Mention is made of pertinent points from patient histories, and an account is given of associated lesions that had been previously operated on or which were treated concomitantly. The subjective results show 82% excellent and good results, and the objective results show 95% excellent and good results. This difference may be explained by the subjective residual pain reported by every patient who suffered a work compensation injury; residual pain was not reported very often by those whose injuries were sports related. Forty-seven patients underwent second-look arthroscopies at one year, and seven underwent arthroscopy at four and five years after operation. These examinations provided very interesting clues as to the graft's future status. It was possible to identify zones of neovascularization, tissue invasion, and unraveling of the graft as well as to test for stability with a probe. Biopsies and histologic studies confirmed superficial and deep ligament revascularization as early as four months after operation. Results of arthroscopy at one year confirmed the results of physical examination and the prognosis for the graft.
本文报告了一项对70例采用未增强的人冻干阔筋膜移植进行关节镜下前交叉韧带重建的研究。总体结果基于主观、客观和影像学检查,以及在1年、4年和5年随访评估时的二次关节镜检查。平均随访时间为4.5年(范围为2至7年)。文中提及了患者病史中的相关要点,并阐述了先前已接受手术治疗或同时接受治疗的相关病变。主观结果显示,优良率为82%;客观结果显示,优良率为95%。这种差异可能是由于每一位遭受工伤赔偿的患者都报告有主观残余疼痛,而运动相关损伤的患者很少报告残余疼痛。47例患者在术后1年接受了二次关节镜检查,7例患者在术后4年和5年接受了关节镜检查。这些检查为移植物的未来状况提供了非常有趣的线索。可以识别出新血管形成区、组织侵入区和移植物松解区,并用探针测试稳定性。活检和组织学研究证实,术后4个月时韧带浅层和深层即出现血管再生。1年时的关节镜检查结果证实了体格检查结果及移植物的预后。