Primatesta P, Goldacre M J
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, University of Oxford, UK.
Int J Epidemiol. 1994 Feb;23(1):155-60. doi: 10.1093/ije/23.1.155.
Appendicectomy is one of the commonest operations in most developed countries, especially in children and young adults. We used routine abstracts of hospital inpatient records to study the demographic and temporal profiles of emergency appendicectomy for acute appendicitis and appendicectomy in other circumstances.
Records held in the Oxford record linkage study (ORLS) from 1970-1986 inclusive were analysed. Age- and sex-specific admission rates were studied, subdividing appendicectomy into three main categories: emergency appendicectomy for acute appendicitis, emergency appendicectomy as the main operation without appendicitis recorded as a diagnosis, and prophylactic or incidental appendicectomy with other operations but without appendicitis.
A total of 47,505 records of appendicectomy were analysed. Emergency appendicectomy for acute appendicitis was more common in males than females, peaked in the 10-19 year age groups, and declined over time. Emergency appendicectomy without appendicitis was more common in women than men (female to male ratio 1.8:1), peaked at age 15-19 years and did not decline over time. Incidental appendicectomy was much commoner in women (female to male ratio 3:1), peaked at older ages than the first two groups, and declined significantly over time.
The demographic profiles of patients in these categories were quite different. The data on trends suggest confirmation of a true decline in acute appendicitis, no decline for conditions which may mimic it, and a decline in the use of prophylactic and incidental appendicectomy. The operations in the latter categories--appendicectomy without acute appendicitis--were much commoner in women than men and their appropriateness would be worthwhile topics for medical audit.
阑尾切除术是大多数发达国家最常见的手术之一,尤其是在儿童和年轻人中。我们使用医院住院记录的常规摘要来研究急性阑尾炎急诊阑尾切除术以及其他情况下阑尾切除术的人口统计学和时间分布情况。
分析了牛津记录链接研究(ORLS)中1970年至1986年(含)的记录。研究了特定年龄和性别的入院率,将阑尾切除术细分为三大类:急性阑尾炎急诊阑尾切除术、以阑尾切除术作为主要手术但未记录阑尾炎为诊断、与其他手术同时进行的预防性或偶然性阑尾切除术但无阑尾炎。
共分析了47505份阑尾切除术记录。急性阑尾炎急诊阑尾切除术男性比女性更常见,在10 - 19岁年龄组达到峰值,并随时间下降。无阑尾炎的急诊阑尾切除术女性比男性更常见(女性与男性比例为1.8:1),在15 - 19岁达到峰值且未随时间下降。偶然性阑尾切除术女性更为常见(女性与男性比例为3:1),在比前两组更大的年龄达到峰值,并随时间显著下降。
这些类别患者的人口统计学特征差异很大。趋势数据表明急性阑尾炎的真实发病率确实下降,可能与之类似的情况发病率未下降,预防性和偶然性阑尾切除术的使用有所下降。后两类手术——无急性阑尾炎的阑尾切除术——女性比男性更常见,其合理性值得医学审计探讨。