Blankenhorn D H, Hodis H N
Atherosclerosis Research Institute, University of Southern California School of Medicine, Los Angeles 90033.
West J Med. 1993 Aug;159(2):172-9.
Evidence for atherosclerosis reversal comes from studies in animals wherein atherosclerosis is induced and then allowed to regress, autopsy studies of starved humans, and angiographic studies testing antiatherosclerosis treatment. Animal models and autopsy studies have provided detailed histologic and biochemical descriptions of regression. Cellular and subcellular information exists on what can occur, but because the same lesions are not re-examined, what actually does occur is unknown. Studies of isolated arterial cell systems and intact lesions indicate that atherogenesis involves at least the following: Increased permeability of the endothelium to macromolecules such as low-density lipoprotein; platelet adherence to areas of functional endothelial injury or denudation; the entrance of monocytes or macrophages and lymphocytes into the subintimal space; and the secretion of growth factors by platelets, injured endothelium, and macrophages. These processes can be initiated or enhanced by various vasoactive agents that induce endothelial cell constriction with the opening of endothelial junctions. These processes also can recruit smooth muscle cells from the media to the subintima where they proliferate. Proliferating smooth muscle cells, along with macrophages, can internalize lipids and lipoproteins to form foam cells. Subintimal smooth muscle cells can also synthesize collagen, elastin, glycosaminoglycans, and other connective tissue elements that trap lipoproteins. Peroxidative injury increases the atherogenic potential of both cholesteryl ester-rich (low-density) and triglyceride-rich (very-low-density and intermediate-density) lipoproteins. Steep oxygen gradients within the arterial wall create local conditions for free radical generation, and any increase in residence time of lipoprotein particles can be atherogenic. In summary, there are many areas where treatment may retard or reverse atherogenesis. Angiographic trials that identify and track individual human lesions have shown that reducing known atherogenic risk factors can lessen coronary and femoral atherosclerosis. But they provide no information on events within arterial wall cells or the intracellular matrix. They deal only with lesions that intrude into the vessel lumen and obtain measurements at infrequent intervals. The weight of evidence is that regression is possible, but there is no consensus on the most effective therapy. The challenge for future trials is to select optimal targets for intervention among the known atherogenic processes.
动脉粥样硬化逆转的证据来自于动物研究(在这些研究中诱导动脉粥样硬化然后使其消退)、对饥饿人类的尸检研究以及测试抗动脉粥样硬化治疗的血管造影研究。动物模型和尸检研究提供了关于消退的详细组织学和生物化学描述。存在关于可能发生情况的细胞和亚细胞信息,但由于没有对相同病变进行重新检查,实际发生的情况尚不清楚。对分离的动脉细胞系统和完整病变的研究表明,动脉粥样硬化的发生至少涉及以下方面:内皮细胞对大分子(如低密度脂蛋白)的通透性增加;血小板黏附于功能性内皮损伤或剥脱区域;单核细胞、巨噬细胞和淋巴细胞进入内膜下间隙;以及血小板、受损内皮细胞和巨噬细胞分泌生长因子。这些过程可由各种血管活性物质引发或增强,这些物质通过内皮连接的开放诱导内皮细胞收缩。这些过程还可将平滑肌细胞从中层募集到内膜下,使其在内膜下增殖。增殖的平滑肌细胞与巨噬细胞一起可摄取脂质和脂蛋白以形成泡沫细胞。内膜下平滑肌细胞还可合成胶原蛋白、弹性蛋白、糖胺聚糖和其他捕获脂蛋白的结缔组织成分。过氧化损伤增加了富含胆固醇酯(低密度)和富含甘油三酯(极低密度和中间密度)脂蛋白的致动脉粥样硬化潜能。动脉壁内的陡峭氧梯度为自由基生成创造了局部条件,脂蛋白颗粒停留时间的任何增加都可能具有致动脉粥样硬化性。总之,有许多治疗可能延缓或逆转动脉粥样硬化发生的领域。识别和跟踪个体人类病变的血管造影试验表明,降低已知的致动脉粥样硬化危险因素可减轻冠状动脉和股动脉粥样硬化。但它们没有提供关于动脉壁细胞内或细胞内基质内事件的信息。它们仅处理侵入血管腔的病变,并以不频繁的间隔进行测量。证据表明逆转是可能的,但对于最有效的治疗方法尚无共识。未来试验面临的挑战是在已知的致动脉粥样硬化过程中选择最佳的干预靶点。