Tattersall M H, Langlands A O, Smith W, Irwig L
Department of Cancer Medicine, University of Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Eur J Cancer. 1993;29A(11):1639-42. doi: 10.1016/0959-8049(93)90314-6.
Undergraduate cancer education in Australian medical schools is not integrated and there is little evidence of change in content or structure in recent years in spite of major changes in knowledge about cancer epidemiology and cancer biology, and in cancer management. A recent survey of graduating students/interns from all Australian medical schools revealed a disturbing variability in experience and lack of important knowledge. There was evidence of substantial differences in knowledge of, and rating of teaching between the different disciplines involved in cancer control and cancer management. To examine possible reasons for this, we surveyed cancer clinicians and teachers of oncology in the undergraduate curriculum at Australian medical schools. We asked them the same questions of knowledge as the students, and also to comment on the type and emphasis of teaching desirable in the medical students' cancer curriculum. The results indicate not only that the survey instrument was seen to be relevant, but also that some of the bias and misinformation detected in the student experiences may be attributed to attitude, knowledge and differences of opinion of the teachers. The results highlight the need for an integrated cancer curriculum to inform graduates about an illness which will be diagnosed in more than a quarter of the Australian population.
澳大利亚医学院校的本科癌症教育并未实现整合,尽管在癌症流行病学、癌症生物学及癌症管理方面的知识有了重大变化,但近年来在教学内容或结构上几乎没有改变的迹象。最近一项针对澳大利亚所有医学院校即将毕业的学生/实习生的调查显示,他们的经历存在令人不安的差异,且缺乏重要知识。有证据表明,参与癌症控制和管理的不同学科在癌症知识掌握程度及教学评价方面存在显著差异。为探究其中可能的原因,我们对澳大利亚医学院校本科课程中的癌症临床医生和肿瘤学教师进行了调查。我们向他们提出了与学生相同的知识问题,并请他们就医学生癌症课程中理想的教学类型和重点发表意见。结果表明,不仅调查工具被认为是相关的,而且在学生经历中发现的一些偏见和错误信息可能归因于教师的态度、知识和意见分歧。这些结果凸显了需要一个整合的癌症课程,以便让毕业生了解这种在超过四分之一的澳大利亚人口中会被诊断出的疾病。