Suominen H
Department of Health Sciences, University of Jyväskylä, Finland.
Sports Med. 1993 Nov;16(5):316-30. doi: 10.2165/00007256-199316050-00003.
Evidence in human studies of the association of long term habitual exercise with bone mineral content (BMC) and density (BMD) largely comes from studies in athletes. In young adults, the highest BMC and BMD values have been found in strength and power-trained athletes, while endurance activities such as long distance running and swimming seem less effective with regard to peak bone density. Intensive endurance training may even be associated with amenorrhoea and decreased trabecular bone density in young females. However, after menopause female athletes show greater bone mass indicating that they do not share the accelerated decline in BMC observed in a nonathletic population. Middle-aged and elderly male athletes from various sports have significantly higher BMC and BMD than controls, especially in trabecular bone sites, but higher cortical BMC has also been found in the dominant/nondominant arm comparisons with unilateral exercises such as tennis. The differences found between female athletes and controls have generally been less pronounced than those among men, but a number of studies suggest that in women long term physical training may counteract the low BMC and BMD associated with reduced bone mass. Although the interpretation of results of cross-sectional studies should be treated with caution, studies in athletes serve as an economical alternative approach to experimental trials with their long term follow-up and exercise compliance problems. The differences found in BMD between those who have devoted themselves to life-long training and those who have been much less active should not be underestimated.
关于长期习惯性运动与骨矿物质含量(BMC)及骨密度(BMD)之间关联的人体研究证据,很大程度上来自对运动员的研究。在年轻人中,力量和爆发力训练的运动员骨矿物质含量和骨密度值最高,而诸如长跑和游泳等耐力运动在增加峰值骨密度方面似乎效果较差。高强度耐力训练甚至可能与年轻女性闭经及骨小梁骨密度降低有关。然而,绝经后女性运动员的骨量更高,这表明她们没有出现非运动员人群中观察到的骨矿物质含量加速下降的情况。来自各类运动项目的中老年男性运动员的骨矿物质含量和骨密度显著高于对照组,尤其是在骨小梁部位,但在与网球等单侧运动相关的优势/非优势手臂比较中,也发现优势手臂的皮质骨矿物质含量更高。女性运动员与对照组之间的差异通常不如男性之间明显,但多项研究表明,长期体育锻炼可能会抵消女性因骨量减少而导致的低骨矿物质含量和低骨密度。尽管横断面研究结果的解读应谨慎对待,但对运动员的研究是一种经济的替代方法,可避免长期随访和运动依从性问题的实验性试验。终生从事训练的人与很少运动的人在骨密度上的差异不应被低估。