Krystal A D, Weiner R D, McCall W V, Shelp F E, Arias R, Smith P
Department of Psychiatry, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710.
Biol Psychiatry. 1993 Dec 1;34(11):759-67. doi: 10.1016/0006-3223(93)90064-k.
Recent evidence suggests that electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) efficacy depends upon both electrode placement and the degree to which stimulus dosage exceeds seizure threshold (T), and not simply on surpassing a minimum seizure duration as has been assumed. In light of these findings and studies reporting ictal electroencephalogram (EEG) differences between bilateral and unilateral ECT, we performed this 19-subject intraindividual crossover study of the effects of dose and electrode placement on the ictal EEG. We found ictal EEG evidence of greater seizure intensity with bilateral than unilateral ECT and with higher dosage (2.25 T) compared with barely suprathreshold stimuli. Seizure duration was not longer with bilateral than unilateral ECT and actually decreased with increased dose. A number of ictal EEG variables separated the unilateral 2.25 T and unilateral T conditions, which reportedly differ in efficacy, and therefore, these EEG measures show promise as markers of treatment adequacy.
近期证据表明,电休克疗法(ECT)的疗效既取决于电极放置,也取决于刺激剂量超过癫痫发作阈值(T)的程度,而不仅仅如之前所认为的那样,仅取决于超过最短癫痫发作持续时间。鉴于这些发现以及报告双侧和单侧ECT发作期脑电图(EEG)差异的研究,我们对19名受试者进行了一项关于剂量和电极放置对发作期EEG影响的个体内交叉研究。我们发现,与单侧ECT相比,双侧ECT发作期EEG显示癫痫发作强度更大,且与刚好高于阈值的刺激相比,高剂量(2.25T)时发作强度更大。双侧ECT的癫痫发作持续时间并不比单侧ECT更长,实际上还随剂量增加而缩短。一些发作期EEG变量区分了单侧2.25T和单侧T的情况,据报道这两种情况疗效不同,因此,这些EEG测量指标有望作为治疗充分性的标志物。