Goldbourt U, Medalie J H
Am J Epidemiol. 1977 Jan;105(1):75-86. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a112358.
Physiologic, biochemical and genetic characteristcs of current smokers, non-smokers and ex-smokers were compared among a study population of almost 10,000 working men aged 40-65 years in Israel. Many significant differences were found, although most differences were small. Current and ex-smokers were slightly taller than non-smokers, and height was correlated to amount smoked. Current smokers had lower weights (absolute and adjusted)8 skunfolds, systolic and distolic blood pressures, and uric acid levels, but had higher pulse rates and higher concentrations of total and beta-cholesterol, hemoglobuin and hematocrit. They showes, however, lower alpha-cholesterol (absolute and relative) concentrations. All the above differences were dose-response-related but discriminant analysis incorporating socio-demographic and behavioral correlates revealed only a moderate degree of combined discrimination. The conclusion is that, while cigarette smokers differ from non-smokers in many ways, the overall difference is umimpressive. This explains why, in prospective analysis, increased mortality and morbidity among smokers could not be attributed to confounding variables. Ex-smokers resembled current smokers in height and cholesterol but were closer to non-smokers levels of weight, skinfolds, blood pressure, uric acid and alpha-cholesterol. Ex-smokers also had inermediate levels of hemoglobin and hematocrit. Cigar and pipe smokers differed from non-smokers only in their elevated levels of cholesterol and uric acid. There was no variation by smoking habits among blood groups of seven types. It is concluded that an overall similarity exists between different smoking groups mainly in terms of coronary risk factors, and that therefore, constitutional differences do no account for the increased mortality and morbidity among smokers.
在以色列近10000名年龄在40至65岁的在职男性研究人群中,对当前吸烟者、非吸烟者和既往吸烟者的生理、生化和遗传特征进行了比较。发现了许多显著差异,尽管大多数差异较小。当前吸烟者和既往吸烟者比非吸烟者略高,且身高与吸烟量相关。当前吸烟者的体重(绝对值和校正值)、皮褶厚度、收缩压和舒张压以及尿酸水平较低,但脉搏率较高,总胆固醇和β-胆固醇、血红蛋白和血细胞比容浓度较高。然而,他们的α-胆固醇(绝对值和相对值)浓度较低。上述所有差异均与剂量反应相关,但纳入社会人口统计学和行为相关性的判别分析仅显示出中等程度的综合判别能力。结论是,虽然吸烟者在许多方面与非吸烟者不同,但总体差异并不显著。这就解释了为什么在前瞻性分析中,吸烟者中死亡率和发病率的增加不能归因于混杂变量。既往吸烟者在身高和胆固醇方面与当前吸烟者相似,但在体重、皮褶厚度、血压、尿酸和α-胆固醇水平上更接近非吸烟者。既往吸烟者的血红蛋白和血细胞比容水平也处于中间水平。雪茄和烟斗吸烟者与非吸烟者的差异仅在于胆固醇和尿酸水平升高。七种血型的吸烟习惯之间没有差异。得出的结论是,不同吸烟群体之间主要在冠状动脉危险因素方面总体相似,因此,体质差异不能解释吸烟者中死亡率和发病率的增加。