Beckwith C, Munger M A
University of Utah Hospital, College of Pharmacy, Salt Lake City.
Ann Pharmacother. 1993 Jun;27(6):755-66. doi: 10.1177/106002809302700617.
To discuss the effects of angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors on ventricular remodeling and survival after acute myocardial infarction (AMI). An overview is provided of the pathophysiologic changes produced by AMI and the ventricular remodeling process. ACE inhibitors have been studied for their use in the prevention of ventricular remodeling and reduction in postinfarction mortality. Trials in humans and animals are reviewed, including study methods, results, and limitations.
MEDLINE searches identified applicable literature, including experimental trials and review articles.
All clinical trials of ACE inhibitors following AMI were reviewed.
Morbidity and mortality data evaluating the effect of postinfarction ventricular remodeling are rare. At the time of publication, all available clinical trials studying the effects of ACE inhibitors on postinfarction ventricular remodeling were included, regardless of whether morbidity and mortality were assessed. Data from the Survival and Ventricular Enlargement (SAVE) and Cooperative New Scandinavian Enalapril Survival Study II (CONSENSUS II) trials include almost 10,000 patients. Data were extracted by two independent observers. Data quality and validity were assessed based on sample size, stratification of study population, and statistical power of the studies.
ACE inhibitors may prevent the deleterious consequences of AMI, including ventricular remodeling and neurohumoral activation. Ventricular hypertrophy begins acutely following infarction, an early physiologic response to myocardial injury. Hemodynamic benefits from the initial phase of left ventricular hypertrophy include increased ventricular working capacity, normalized systolic wall stress, and maintenance of stroke volume. Although acute dilatation may delay hemodynamic deterioration for six to eight months, it also results in reduced coronary reserve, decreased ventricular compliance, and altered myocardial contractility. With chronic dilatation, the beneficial effects reach a plateau, stroke volume decreases, contractility is reduced, and cardiac failure may ensue. Ventricular hypertrophy is associated with worsened prognosis following infarction and may be the most important single determinant of late prognosis. Ventricular hypertrophy contributes to postinfarction heart failure, angina, and sudden death. Clinical trials show a beneficial effect of the ACE inhibitor captopril on the prevention of left ventricular dysfunction. Although captopril therapy significantly improved survival and myocardial function following AMI in the SAVE trial, these results cannot be generalized to all patient subpopulations. The CONSENSUS II trial demonstrated a decreased survival rate when enalapril was administered within 24 hours of AMI, indicating that timing of therapy may be an important consideration. Captopril therapy may positively affect outcome when initiated 3-16 days following infarction in patients with ejection fractions below 40 percent and who have no signs of ischemia or heart failure. Based on the CONSENSUS II results, enalapril therapy immediately following AMI cannot be recommended.
Clinical trials have demonstrated that ACE inhibitors can limit ventricular hypertrophy following AMI, resulting in clinical benefit and improved survival. These effects may be secondary to modulation of neurohumoral activation or the antiischemic effect of ACE inhibitors, which may also reduce the incidence of reinfarction. Early intervention with ACE inhibitors (within 3-16 days of infarction) can slow the progression of cardiovascular disease and improve the survival rate.
探讨血管紧张素转换酶(ACE)抑制剂对急性心肌梗死(AMI)后心室重构及生存率的影响。本文概述了AMI所产生的病理生理变化及心室重构过程。对ACE抑制剂用于预防心室重构及降低梗死后死亡率的情况进行了研究。回顾了在人类和动物身上进行的试验,包括研究方法、结果及局限性。
通过医学文献数据库(MEDLINE)检索确定了适用文献,包括试验性研究和综述文章。
对所有AMI后使用ACE抑制剂的临床试验进行了回顾。
评估梗死后心室重构影响的发病率和死亡率数据较为少见。在撰写本文时,纳入了所有研究ACE抑制剂对梗死后心室重构影响的现有临床试验,无论是否评估了发病率和死亡率。生存与心室扩大(SAVE)试验及新斯堪的纳维亚依那普利生存协作研究II(CONSENSUS II)试验的数据涵盖了近10,000名患者。数据由两名独立观察者提取。基于样本量、研究人群分层及研究的统计学效力对数据质量和有效性进行了评估。
ACE抑制剂可能预防AMI的有害后果,包括心室重构和神经体液激活。梗死发生后心室肥厚立即开始,这是对心肌损伤的早期生理反应。左心室肥厚初始阶段的血流动力学益处包括心室工作能力增加、收缩期壁应力正常化及维持每搏输出量。尽管急性扩张可能将血流动力学恶化推迟6至8个月,但它也会导致冠状动脉储备减少、心室顺应性降低及心肌收缩性改变。随着慢性扩张,有益作用达到平台期,每搏输出量减少,收缩性降低,可能会引发心力衰竭。心室肥厚与梗死后预后恶化相关,可能是晚期预后最重要的单一决定因素。心室肥厚会导致梗死后心力衰竭、心绞痛及猝死。临床试验表明ACE抑制剂卡托普利对预防左心室功能障碍有有益作用。尽管在SAVE试验中卡托普利治疗显著改善了AMI后的生存率和心肌功能,但这些结果不能推广至所有患者亚组。CONSENSUS II试验表明,在AMI后24小时内给予依那普利会使生存率降低,这表明治疗时机可能是一个重要的考虑因素。对于射血分数低于40%且无缺血或心力衰竭迹象的患者,在梗死3 - 16天后开始卡托普利治疗可能会对结局产生积极影响。基于CONSENSUS II试验结果,不推荐AMI后立即使用依那普利治疗。
临床试验表明,ACE抑制剂可限制AMI后的心室肥厚,带来临床益处并提高生存率。这些作用可能继发于对神经体液激活的调节或ACE抑制剂的抗缺血作用,这也可能降低再梗死的发生率。早期使用ACE抑制剂干预(梗死3 - 16天内)可减缓心血管疾病进展并提高生存率。