Nicolai N, Mangiarotti B, Salvioni R, Piva L, Faustini M, Pizzocaro G
Department of Surgery, Istituto Nationale Tumori, Milan, Italy.
Eur Urol. 1993;23(4):450-6. doi: 10.1159/000474651.
Thirty-six consecutive patients, who were to be treated with cisplatin-based chemotherapy for testicular or bladder cancer, underwent a single-blind randomized study to compare the antiemetic therapies with dexamethasone (DEX)+ondansetron (OND) and DEX + alizapride (ALI). Eighteen patients were assigned to each arm. DEX, 20 mg in 100 ml saline was administered i.v. 30 min prior to cisplatin, OND, 8 mg, or ALI, 100 mg in 100 ml saline were administered i.v. 15 min prior to cisplatin and repeated 4 and eventually 8 h later. Chemotherapy regimens contained cisplatin 25 mg/m2 for 4 consecutive days to be repeated for 4 courses every 4 weeks. During the first course a complete emetic control was observed in 15 (83%) and partial in 3 of the 18 patients treated with DEX + OND versus only 2 complete and 7 partial responses and 9 (50%) failures among the 18 patients treated with DEX + ALI. Thirty-one patients were evaluable for 4 courses of therapy. Complete emetic control was achieved in 11 (69%) and partial in 5 (31%) among the 16 patients treated with DEX + OND, versus only 1 (7%) partial response and 14 (93%) failures among the 15 treated with DEX + ALI (p < 0.001). Furthermore, DEX + OND gave a complete antiemetic control in 13 out of 14 patients who had failed DEX + ALI. Delayed vomiting was observed in 4 (22%) of 18 patients primarily treated with DEX + OND and in 1 (7%) of the 15 patients subsequently treated. Constipation and headache occurred more frequently among patients treated with DEX + OND, but there was no significant difference with DEX + ALI. Hiccup was significantly more frequent among patients treated with DEX + ALI.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
36例即将接受以顺铂为基础的化疗治疗睾丸癌或膀胱癌的患者,进行了一项单盲随机研究,以比较地塞米松(DEX)+昂丹司琼(OND)和DEX+阿立必利(ALI)的止吐疗法。每组分配18例患者。在顺铂给药前30分钟静脉注射100 ml生理盐水中含20 mg的DEX,在顺铂给药前15分钟静脉注射100 ml生理盐水中含8 mg的OND或100 mg的ALI,并在4小时后最终在8小时后重复给药。化疗方案为连续4天每天使用顺铂25 mg/m²,每4周重复4个疗程。在第一个疗程中,接受DEX+OND治疗的18例患者中有15例(83%)完全控制呕吐,3例部分控制;而接受DEX+ALI治疗的18例患者中只有2例完全缓解,7例部分缓解,9例(50%)未缓解。31例患者可评估4个疗程的治疗。接受DEX+OND治疗的16例患者中有11例(69%)完全控制呕吐,5例(31%)部分控制;而接受DEX+ALI治疗的15例患者中只有1例(7%)部分缓解,14例(93%)未缓解(p<0.001)。此外,在接受DEX+ALI治疗失败的14例患者中,DEX+OND使13例患者完全控制呕吐。在最初接受DEX+OND治疗的18例患者中有4例(22%)出现延迟性呕吐,在随后接受治疗的15例患者中有1例(7%)出现延迟性呕吐。接受DEX+OND治疗的患者便秘和头痛的发生率更高,但与DEX+ALI相比无显著差异。接受DEX+ALI治疗的患者打嗝明显更频繁。(摘要截短于250字)