Galil M A, Critchley M, Mackie C R
University Department of Surgery, Royal Liverpool University Hospital.
Gut. 1993 Jul;34(7):916-9. doi: 10.1136/gut.34.7.916.
Tests of gastric emptying with modern scintigraphic methods are recommended in the clinical management of gastric disorders. An audit of 472 gastric emptying tests carried out over a 10 year period was performed to discover the reasons for requests from consultant clinicians, their anticipation of the results of tests, and the influence of the results upon the subsequent management of their patients. Excluding control (n = 47) and research (n = 50) studies, there were 375 clinical referrals that could be grouped under the headings: non-ulcer dyspepsia (n = 72), suspected diabetic gastroparesis (n = 18), peptic ulcer (n = 15), suspected delayed gastric emptying after surgery (n = 154), dumping and diarrhoea (= 107), and other indications (n = 9). Although the results were abnormal for 55 (48%) of the 'medical' patients, they did not seem to influence clinical management. Delayed gastric emptying after surgery was confirmed in only 20% of patients referred with this clinical diagnosis. Conversely, most (79%) o the patients referred with dumping and diarrhoea exhibited abnormally rapid emptying. Isotope gastric emptying studies may be useful in clinical practice. The results are often at variance with the clinical diagnosis. Clinicians must take into account the nature of the test meal used when results are correlated with clinical features.
在胃部疾病的临床管理中,建议使用现代闪烁扫描法进行胃排空测试。我们对10年间进行的472例胃排空测试进行了审核,以查明会诊临床医生提出申请的原因、他们对测试结果的预期,以及测试结果对其患者后续管理的影响。排除对照研究(n = 47)和研究性研究(n = 50)后,有375例临床转诊病例,可归类为:非溃疡性消化不良(n = 72)、疑似糖尿病胃轻瘫(n = 18)、消化性溃疡(n = 15)、疑似术后胃排空延迟(n = 154)、倾倒综合征和腹泻(n = 107)以及其他指征(n = 9)。尽管“内科”患者中有55例(48%)的结果异常,但这些结果似乎并未影响临床管理。在以术后胃排空延迟为临床诊断转诊的患者中,仅20%得到证实。相反,以倾倒综合征和腹泻转诊的患者中,大多数(79%)表现出排空异常迅速。同位素胃排空研究在临床实践中可能有用。其结果往往与临床诊断不一致。临床医生在将结果与临床特征相关联时,必须考虑所用测试餐的性质。