Marinoff S C, Turner M L, Hirsch R P, Richard G
George Washington University School of Medicine and Health Sciences, Washington, D.C.
J Reprod Med. 1993 Jan;38(1):19-24.
The cost-effectiveness of two treatment strategies for vulvar vestibulitis syndrome (VVS) was compared. Our prospective study consisted of 55 patients with human papillomavirus (HPV)- and non-HPV-associated VVS of at least 6 months' duration treated with intralesional recombinant alpha interferon injections, followed by surgery for nonresponders and responders compared with a hypothetical model of surgery alone. The setting was a private-practice multispecialty center for vulvovaginal disorders. Improvement was defined by patients' subjective evaluation of change in the level of introital dyspareunia and the ability to have sexual relations and objective evidence of change in the degree of erythema and tenderness to touch within the vestibule. Statistical analyses of the overall probability of improvement, overall costs and the cost per patient treated were done. Twenty-seven (49%) of 55 patients treated with alpha interferon had substantial or partial improvement. Of the 28 (51%) who did not improve following alpha interferon, 19 elected to have surgery. Surgery resulted in substantial improvement in 84% of the patients and partial improvement in 11%. Statistical analysis comparing the group treated with alpha interferon (some of whom went to surgery with the hypothetical model of surgical treatment alone) showed significant cost-saving in the group first treated with alpha interferon. At the level of effectiveness achieved in this study, intralesional alpha interferon as a first choice in the treatment of VVS is cost-effective.
比较了两种治疗外阴前庭炎综合征(VVS)策略的成本效益。我们的前瞻性研究纳入了55例人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)相关和非HPV相关的VVS患者,病程至少6个月,采用病灶内注射重组α干扰素治疗,对无反应者和有反应者随后进行手术,并与单纯手术的假设模型进行比较。研究地点是一家治疗外阴阴道疾病的私人多专科中心。改善的定义为患者对外阴性交困难程度变化和发生性关系能力的主观评估,以及前庭红斑程度和触痛变化的客观证据。对改善的总体概率、总成本和每位接受治疗患者的成本进行了统计分析。55例接受α干扰素治疗的患者中,27例(49%)有显著或部分改善。在28例(51%)α干扰素治疗后未改善的患者中,19例选择了手术。手术使84%的患者有显著改善,11%的患者有部分改善。比较接受α干扰素治疗的组(其中一些人接受了手术)与单纯手术治疗的假设模型的统计分析显示,先接受α干扰素治疗的组有显著成本节约。在本研究达到的疗效水平上,病灶内注射α干扰素作为VVS治疗的首选具有成本效益。