Imperatrice C A, Nachamkin I
Department of Pathology, Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia 19104-4283.
J Clin Microbiol. 1993 Feb;31(2):433-5. doi: 10.1128/jcm.31.2.433-435.1993.
We evaluated the Vitek EPS card as a screen for the enteric pathogens Salmonella spp., Shigella spp., and Yersinia enterocolitica. Salmonella spp., Shigella spp., and Y. enterocolitica (125, 54, and 5 isolates, respectively) and 81 nonenteric pathogens that might be selected for screening from primary plates (non-lactose fermenters) were tested. The EPS card correctly identified 183 of 184 pathogens tested (sensitivity, 99.5%). Of 81 nonenteric pathogens screened with the EPS card, 8 were identified as possible enteric pathogens (specificity, 90.1%). We reviewed our stool culture records over the past 1.5 years and analyzed the specificities of TSI-urea screens for 300 stool cultures that had suspicious colonies. From 55 of 300 stool cultures, either Salmonella spp. or Shigella spp. were isolated, and from 245 stool cultures, no pathogen was isolated. Of the 245 negative cultures, 166 gave false-positive screening-test results that resulted in further biochemical identification procedures (Analytab Products or Vitek identification). Thus, the specificity of the TSI-urea screen in our experience was 32.2%. The Vitek EPS card was shown to be a more cost-effective screening procedure than the TSI-urea screen.
我们评估了Vitek EPS卡作为筛查肠道病原体沙门氏菌属、志贺氏菌属和小肠结肠炎耶尔森菌的工具。对沙门氏菌属、志贺氏菌属和小肠结肠炎耶尔森菌(分别为125株、54株和5株分离株)以及81种可能从原始平板(非乳糖发酵菌)中选择用于筛查的非肠道病原体进行了测试。EPS卡正确识别了184株测试病原体中的183株(敏感性为99.5%)。在用EPS卡筛查的81种非肠道病原体中,有8种被鉴定为可能的肠道病原体(特异性为90.1%)。我们回顾了过去1.5年的粪便培养记录,并分析了300份有可疑菌落的粪便培养物的TSI-尿素筛查的特异性。在300份粪便培养物中,有55份分离出了沙门氏菌属或志贺氏菌属,245份粪便培养物未分离出病原体。在245份阴性培养物中,有166份给出了假阳性筛查试验结果,导致了进一步的生化鉴定程序(Analytab Products或Vitek鉴定)。因此,根据我们的经验,TSI-尿素筛查的特异性为32.2%。结果表明,Vitek EPS卡是一种比TSI-尿素筛查更具成本效益的筛查程序。