Walker E F, Lewine R R
Dept. of Psychology, Emory University, Atlanta, GA 30322.
Schizophr Bull. 1993;19(1):1-7; discussion 9-14. doi: 10.1093/schbul/19.1.1.
Gender differences in schizophrenia are of great interest to researchers, and some have recently concluded that female patients suffer from a more benign form of the illness. However, the research findings do not support this conclusion consistently, and some reports suggest greater impairment in female patients. In this article, we discuss the potential effects of sampling biases on the findings from studies that compare male and female patients. More specifically, we assume that females do manifest a less severe schizophrenic illness than males, and we propose that sex differences in severity thresholds for voluntary and involuntary treatment are contributing to inconsistencies in the research findings. Some other sources of sampling bias that may influence findings on gender differences are also discussed.
精神分裂症中的性别差异引起了研究人员的极大兴趣,最近一些人得出结论,女性患者患的是病情较轻的一种疾病形式。然而,研究结果并不始终支持这一结论,一些报告表明女性患者的损害更大。在本文中,我们讨论了抽样偏差对比较男性和女性患者的研究结果的潜在影响。更具体地说,我们假设女性确实比男性表现出的精神分裂症病情较轻,并且我们提出自愿治疗和非自愿治疗的严重程度阈值中的性别差异导致了研究结果的不一致。还讨论了可能影响性别差异研究结果的其他一些抽样偏差来源。