Ebell M H, Preston P S
Department of Family Medicine, Wayne State University.
Fam Med. 1993 Mar;25(3):191-6.
The purpose of this analysis is to determine the effect of the Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE) II score and other clinical variables on survival following cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and to identify patient subpopulations with extremely poor survival.
A retrospective chart review was performed on 218 consecutive adult inpatients undergoing CPR on the general wards and in the intensive care units of a community hospital between January 1, 1989, and July 1, 1991. The patient's age, sex, prior residence, reason for admission, discharge diagnoses, discharge disposition, APACHE II score, and cardiac ejection fraction by echocardiography were recorded.
The age, sex, and reason for admission were not significant predictors of survival following CPR. Multiple variable analysis revealed that an increasing APACHE II score (P = .05), a serum creatinine greater than 311 mumol per L (3.5 mg per dL, P = .02), and metastatic cancer (P = .04) were each related to a decreased rate of survival to discharge following CPR. Patient subpopulations with a 0% rate of survival to discharge included those with metastatic cancer (n = 26, P = .02), a serum creatinine greater than 311 mumol per L (3.5 mg per dL) on admission (n = 22, P = .03), and a diagnosis of cardiovascular disease with an APACHE II score greater than 15 on admission (n = 18, P = .007).
The APACHE II score is a useful predictor of failure to survive to discharge following CPR. Several groups of patients were identified with negligible rates of survival to discharge. Physicians should use such prediagnostic information to provide patients with informed consent when discussing do-not-resuscitate (DNR) orders. We suggest that physicians make a special effort to address the DNR status of patients falling to one of the negligible-survival groups identified by this study.
本分析旨在确定急性生理与慢性健康状况评估(APACHE)II评分及其他临床变量对心肺复苏(CPR)后生存的影响,并识别生存极差的患者亚群。
对1989年1月1日至1991年7月1日期间在一家社区医院普通病房和重症监护病房连续接受CPR的218例成年住院患者进行回顾性病历审查。记录患者的年龄、性别、先前居住地、入院原因、出院诊断、出院处置、APACHE II评分以及超声心动图测定的心脏射血分数。
年龄、性别和入院原因并非CPR后生存的显著预测因素。多变量分析显示,APACHE II评分升高(P = 0.05)、血清肌酐大于311μmol/L(3.5mg/dL,P = 0.02)以及转移性癌症(P = 0.04)均与CPR后出院生存率降低相关。出院生存率为0%的患者亚群包括患有转移性癌症的患者(n = 26,P = 0.02)、入院时血清肌酐大于311μmol/L(3.5mg/dL)的患者(n = 22,P = 0.03)以及入院时APACHE II评分大于15的心血管疾病诊断患者(n = 18,P = 0.007)。
APACHE II评分是CPR后出院生存失败的有用预测指标。识别出了几组出院生存率极低的患者。医生在讨论不进行心肺复苏(DNR)医嘱时,应利用此类预诊断信息为患者提供知情同意。我们建议医生特别关注本研究确定的生存可忽略不计组中的患者的DNR状态。