Smith J, Birchwood M, Cochrane R, George S
Barnsley Hall Hospital, Bromsgrove, UK.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 1993 Feb;28(1):11-6. doi: 10.1007/BF00797827.
Comparison of the needs and characteristics of relatives classified as high and low expressed emotion (EE) across a range of measures including social functioning and indices of stress and family burden revealed that high EE relatives reported higher levels of disturbed behaviour, subjective burden, and perceived themselves as coping less effectively. Individuals from high-EE households were more impaired in terms of social functioning, particularly in terms of independence and interpersonal functioning. No difference in overall knowledge about schizophrenia was observed between high and low EE relatives, although high EE relatives possessed more information about hospital procedures. Analysis of needs assessment data, based on a normative approach to need, revealed that two-thirds of high EE relatives, as against one-third of low EE relatives had high needs in at least one or more of the following five areas: knowledge about schizophrenia, subjective burden, personal stress, behavioural disturbance and perceived coping. No low EE relative had high needs on all five criteria. The implications of the results for the meaning and genesis of EE and for service provision are considered.
对被归类为高表达情绪(EE)和低表达情绪的亲属在一系列指标(包括社会功能、压力指数和家庭负担)方面的需求和特征进行比较后发现,高EE亲属报告的行为障碍、主观负担水平更高,且认为自己应对能力较差。来自高EE家庭的个体在社会功能方面受损更严重,尤其是在独立性和人际功能方面。高EE和低EE亲属在对精神分裂症的总体了解上没有差异,尽管高EE亲属拥有更多关于医院程序的信息。基于需求的规范方法对需求评估数据进行分析后发现,三分之二的高EE亲属在以下五个领域中的至少一个或多个方面有高需求:对精神分裂症的了解、主观负担、个人压力、行为障碍和感知应对能力,而低EE亲属中这一比例为三分之一。没有低EE亲属在所有五个标准上都有高需求。文中考虑了这些结果对EE的意义和成因以及服务提供的影响。