Almond P S, Matas A, Gillingham K, Dunn D L, Payne W D, Gores P, Gruessner R, Najarian J S
Department of Surgery, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis 55455.
Transplantation. 1993 Apr;55(4):752-6; discussion 756-7. doi: 10.1097/00007890-199304000-00013.
Chronic rejection is a major barrier to long-term renal allograft survival. Cyclosporine, though effective at reducing graft loss to acute rejection, has had little impact on the incidence of chronic rejection. Between June 2, 1986 and January 22, 1991, 587 kidney-alone transplants (566 patients) were performed, and had been entered into our renal transplant database and had at least 1 year of follow-up: 103 with biopsy-proven chronic rejection (37 living-related donor, 66 cadaver) and 484 without chronic rejection (236 LRD 248 CAD). The 5-year patient survival was 84% for recipients with biopsy-proven chronic rejection vs. 89% without (P = .08). The 5-year graft survival was 31% for recipients with biopsy-proven chronic rejection vs. 81% without (P < .0001). Using multivariate analysis, we determined the impact on the incidence of chronic rejection of these variables: transplant number, age at transplant (< 18 years, 18 to 50 years, > 50 years), gender, human leukocyte antigen matching, peak and transplant panel-reactive antibody, acute rejection episodes, infections (including cytomegalovirus, viral, and bacterial), donor age, and CsA dosage at 1 year (< 5 mg/kg vs. > or = 5 mg/kg). Logistic regression models were fit to the data using a forward stepwise selection procedure. In this analysis, risk factors included an acute rejection episode (P < .001), CsA dosage < 5 mg/kg/day at 1 year (P = .007), infection (P = .023), female gender (P = .042), and retransplant (P = .103). Individual analyses were done for CAD and LRD recipients. For both groups, important variables were acute rejection, infection, CsA dosage at 1 year, and age at transplant. In conclusion, acute rejection, CsA dosage < 5 mg/kg/day at 1 year, and infection are the major risk factors for the development of chronic rejection, suggesting that chronic rejection may be the result of inadequate immunosuppression (acute rejection episodes and low CsA dosage) or the production of inflammatory cytokines (infections).
慢性排斥反应是长期肾移植存活的主要障碍。环孢素虽然能有效减少急性排斥导致的移植肾丢失,但对慢性排斥反应的发生率影响甚微。1986年6月2日至1991年1月22日期间,共进行了587例单纯肾移植手术(涉及566例患者),这些病例均已录入我们的肾移植数据库且至少随访1年:其中103例经活检证实发生慢性排斥反应(37例为活体亲属供肾,66例为尸体供肾),484例未发生慢性排斥反应(236例活体亲属供肾,248例尸体供肾)。经活检证实发生慢性排斥反应的受者5年患者生存率为84%,未发生慢性排斥反应的受者为89%(P = 0.08)。经活检证实发生慢性排斥反应的受者5年移植肾生存率为31%,未发生慢性排斥反应的受者为81%(P < 0.0001)。通过多因素分析,我们确定了以下变量对慢性排斥反应发生率的影响:移植次数、移植时年龄(<18岁、18至50岁、>50岁)、性别、人类白细胞抗原配型、峰值和移植组反应性抗体、急性排斥反应发作次数、感染(包括巨细胞病毒、病毒和细菌感染)、供者年龄以及1年时的环孢素剂量(<5mg/kg与≥5mg/kg)。使用向前逐步选择程序将逻辑回归模型拟合到数据中。在该分析中,危险因素包括急性排斥反应发作(P < 0.001)、1年时环孢素剂量<5mg/kg/天(P = 0.007)、感染(P = 0.023)、女性性别(P = 0.042)和再次移植(P = 0.103)。对尸体供肾和活体亲属供肾受者分别进行了分析。对于两组而言,重要变量均为急性排斥反应、感染、1年时的环孢素剂量和移植时年龄。总之,急性排斥反应、1年时环孢素剂量<5mg/kg/天以及感染是发生慢性排斥反应的主要危险因素,这表明慢性排斥反应可能是免疫抑制不足(急性排斥反应发作和低环孢素剂量)或炎性细胞因子产生(感染)的结果。