Graetz B
Department of Sociology, La Trobe University, Bundoora, VIC, Australia.
Soc Sci Med. 1993 Mar;36(6):715-24. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(93)90032-y.
This study examines the impact of employment and unemployment on psychological health and well-being, as measured by the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ). Using longitudinal data, it traces health changes over time for a variety of groups and through a variety of labour market experiences: during sustained employment and unemployment, in the transition from school to employment and unemployment, and as people move between employment and unemployment and between satisfying and unsatisfying jobs. The results show that employed people report significantly lower levels of health disorder than students and the unemployed. These differences are largely unaffected by demographic attributes, living arrangements, socioeconomic status or immediate labour market experiences, and can be attributed to employment status itself rather than predisposing health differences. However, the health consequences of employment and unemployment are directly contingent upon quality of work. As a result, the highest levels of health risk are found amongst dissatisfied workers and the lowest levels amongst satisfied workers. In between these two extremes lie employed people neither satisfied nor dissatisfied with their jobs, unemployed people irrespective of duration, and students. These results indicate that what happens in the workplace has even more impact on a person's health than success or failure in finding a job and keeping it.
本研究考察了就业和失业对心理健康及幸福感的影响,这是通过一般健康问卷(GHQ)来衡量的。利用纵向数据,它追踪了不同群体在不同劳动力市场经历下随时间的健康变化:在持续就业和失业期间、从学校到就业和失业的过渡阶段,以及人们在就业和失业之间、在满意和不满意的工作之间转换时的健康变化。结果表明,就业者报告的健康问题水平显著低于学生和失业者。这些差异在很大程度上不受人口统计学特征、生活安排、社会经济地位或近期劳动力市场经历的影响,可归因于就业状况本身而非预先存在的健康差异。然而,就业和失业对健康的影响直接取决于工作质量。因此,健康风险最高的是对工作不满意的工人,而最低的是对工作满意的工人。在这两个极端之间的是对工作既不满意也不不满意的就业者、不论失业时长的失业者以及学生。这些结果表明,工作场所发生的事情对一个人的健康的影响甚至比找到工作并保住工作的成败更大。